Would you say AI was better than prime T-Mac?

[BigTyme Records]

AI dragged his team to the FINALS



Tmac couldn't couldn't even get out the first round!!

Some people even said tmac was better than kobe at the time ......n before somebody bring up competition these dudes played on the SAME conference


Who yall think is better ?

 

[Remote]

I'll take Prime Tmac.

 

[JetFueledThoughts]

Primetime TMac probably has the better highlight reel, but if I need one player to take my team somewhere, I'm taking AI, everyday.

 

[KingJay]

AI was better. TMac had more talent, but few players ever could dominate a game the way AI did. His heart gives him the edge. What he did in 2000-01 was legendary. He had like 6 or 7 games of ~45+ points in that playoff run

 

[BigTyme Records]

Remember yall tmac was bringing his team absolutely nowhere

 

[Flight]

Man idk..prime T-Mac was 32/6/5. He would win MVP today with those numbers.

 

[BigTyme Records]

Man idk..prime T-Mac was 32/6/5. He would win MVP today with those numbers.

AI put up 33/4/4 in 06......thats not even his best season

 

[threattonature]

I'd take prime T-Mac. But overall AI had the better career. T-Mac was much better on defense and not far off on offense. AI went to the finals due to having the perfect team built around him. The teams T-Mac had around him in Orlando were absolutely horrible and by the time he got to Houston the injuries were starting to catch up.

 

[Flight]

AI put up 33/4/4 in 06......thats not even his best season

I guess I'm guilty of looking at the height aspect of it as well. T-Mac was 6'8 with guard type fluidity. shyt I'm not angry with either selection.

 

[J-MIL]

Nah

 

[intruder]

I would NOT pick prime AI over prime T-Mac. T-Mac all day everyday.

HOWEVER

AI is far more accomplished that T-Mac and carried a band of scrubs on his back to the finals so in that sense, yes AI is a better player than McGrady. I wanna say AI is like WestBrook and T-Mac is like Durant. AI would take dumb shots but will his team to a win. McGrady was just a dynamic scorer and great overall player who was damn near unstoppable in his prime. Everytime i see KD play all i can think about is T-Mac

 

[bucks3115]

A.I is the the basketball god for me

 

[Brandon M.]

ai by a strong margin lol

 

[BigTyme Records]

I would NOT pick prime AI over prime T-Mac. T-Mac all day everyday.

HOWEVER

AI is far more accomplished that T-Mac and carried a band of scrubs on his back to the finals so in that sense, yes AI is a better player than McGrady. I wanna say AI is like WestBrook and T-Mac is like Durant. AI would take dumb shots but will his team to a win. McGrady was just a dynamic scorer and great overall player who was damn near unstoppable in his prime. Everytime i see KD play all i can think about is T-Mac

KD> tmac but i understand

 

[BlueHeffner]

Is this a serious question?


Prime Tmac was on Goatbe's level



Mac all day