Zab Judah (prime) vs. Adrien Broner @welterweight..who wins?

S

spencerforhire

All Star
Joined
Jun 21, 2014
Messages
2,650
Reputation
-2,014
Daps
6,144
Imagine Zab Judah in his prime, fresh after beating Corey Spinks in the 2005 rematch for the WBA, WBC, & IBF Welterweight crown, steps into the ring with Adrien Broner fresh after beating Paul Malinaggi (and before losing to Marcos Maidana) in 2013.

Who would win if these two got into the ring?
 
Last edited:
Newzz

Newzz

"The Truth" always prevails
Supporter
Joined
May 10, 2012
Messages
44,924
Reputation
7,480
Daps
104,638
spencerforhire said:
Imagine Zab Judah in his prime, fresh after beating Corey Spinks in the 2005 rematch for the WBA, WBC, & IBF Welterweight crown, steps into the ring with Adrien Broner fresh after beating Paul Malinaggi (and before losing to Marcos Maidana) in 2013.

Who would win if these two got into the ring?
Click to expand...

The fight should be them at 140, but to answer your question, it depends on who's less distracted outside the ring.


Judah lost to Carlos Baldomir at 147....Broner lost to Maidana & Porter.


Im taking AB because Judah always broke down mentally & gassed in fights where he didn't have the upperhand, AB fought back like he did vs Maidana and Porter (in the last round).
 
Skip b

Skip b

#SwiftSet
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
19,400
Reputation
-75
Daps
20,989
Reppin
Swiftset
The guy that has Malinaggi problems, vs the guy that took a L an got put on his ass by malinaggi, hmmm.....:ehh:

Broner doesnt beat the pre tyzsu Zab, nor the Zab that troubled cotto.....Prime Zab was just a different level of fighter although their careers are on a similar tragectory
 
Columbo

Columbo

Lieutenant
Joined
Mar 15, 2015
Messages
8,928
Reputation
2,066
Daps
28,489
Reppin
Homicide Investigations
I was thinking tonight that they remind me of eachother a little

Actually i was thinking of Broner starting to look like an older Judah with good defensive but no enough offensive output

Im gonna go with Judah at his best, but one thing ill say about Broner is he has a very good chin, something i realized in the Maidana fight despite hin getting dropped

Broner impressed me by making it through that fight. Judah looked on par with Mayweather for half their fight, he was a great athlete

*edit

Sidenote: how long until @Aswad gets banned for spamming? :sas2:

Not even that big of a Broner fan, hes aiight to me. But in thinking about negging Asswad:jbhmm:

*double edit

The nikkas been drinking, he gets a pass
 
Last edited:
gho3st

gho3st

plata or plomo
Joined
Oct 27, 2012
Messages
35,251
Reputation
3,155
Daps
85,679
Reppin
2016
Newzz said:
The fight should be them at 140, but to answer your question, it depends on who's less distracted outside the ring.


Judah lost to Carlos Baldomir at 147....Broner lost to Maidana & Porter.


Im taking AB because Judah always broke down mentally & gassed in fights where he didn't have the upperhand, AB fought back like he did vs Maidana and Porter (in the last round).
Click to expand...
you :troll: no way zab loses to broner :heh:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top