I like how you ignored most of my post and ignored @IllmaticDelta post. But whatever.
Who the heck said Rapping is ALL Hip Hip? Hip Hop includes many things. But rapping is one of the main elements of Hip Hop.
And yet you like to champion yourself as this mega Hip Hop historian???
DJ Kool Herc did not rap and he only did the two turntables from disco later iirc.
Yes I AGREE balance is NEEDED, like everyone in this thread has stated. Too much lyricism over flow is bad(i.e Eminem and Hopsin). And too much flow over lyricism is bad(i.e these one hit wonders).
The thing is you're acting like lyricism/rapping is not one of the main focal points of Hip Hop. The very thing that separates Hip Hop from Funk/Soul, R&B, Rock, Pop,etc. This post indirectly agrees with me. How much is Hip Hip different from Funk/Soul without rapping/lyricism??
It's an irrelevant point. You could argue that people rapped even before that.
Rapping is NOT hip hop. It's an element of hip hop.
Who the heck said Rapping is ALL Hip Hip? Hip Hop includes many things. But rapping is one of the main elements of Hip Hop.
Nonsense. "Hip Hop" is heterogeneous in origins. It has many roots. One of the main roots being DJing/breaking(disco), rapping, dancing and graffiti. The DJing that Kool Herc did ALSO existed prior to Hip Hop. So your point with graffiti existing before Hip Hop??? Mines and IllmaticDelta's point about Hip Hop being largely influenced by Disco/Funk flew past your head. Without rapping, Hip Hop would be vastly similar to disco.Hip hop is a specific genre of music that got created when Kool Herc stepped in. A specific place: The Bronx. A specific time: 1974. All the other shyt beforehand are just things that people did that would later become part of hip hop culture. Graffiti existed prior to hip hop.
Hip hop MUSIC is the center of these elements. What brought all these random activities people did (djing with two turntables from disco, rapping, graffiti, even elements of dancing) into one cohesive culture. And that music did not exist until Kool Herc.
And yet you like to champion yourself as this mega Hip Hop historian???

Whose denying the bolded? The point is without rapping/lyricism Hip Hop would be no different from other musical genres.I wish I could find the video that explains this, because I remember some legend making this exact point. saying that hip hop music didn't exist till Kool Herc. The things that make up hip hop existed prior to hip hop, but hip hop is a musical mix of all that. So all that disco DJ, hustlers convention stuff is beside the point.
This post basically agrees with me.I went to a seminar recently with Kid Capri and he echoed this sentiment. The reality of the matter is that James Brown was basically the first rapper, if you really think about it. Until James Brown invented the emphasis on the downbeat, rapping got buried in the instrumentation. It didn't have any edge. The emphasis on the downbeat allowed rapping as we know it today to even exist. James Brown gave rapping the edge it needed to really stand out because James pretty much invented the first hard beat in history.
Which means one very key thing: hip hop is funk on steroids. It has elements of other stuff, but the core of hip hop is funk/soul. Period. It's not disco. It's not reggae. It's not spoken word. It's not even 100% James Brown.
The whole point of this thread is to state that hip hop has fallen off because people don't respect its musical roots, which is mainly funk/soul and a bunch of other stuff. Instead, you get lames today who think it's 100% spoken word and bars. The idiots that focus on 'lyricism' to the complete detriment of the funk. And the funk (the hard music that starts parties and gets people moving) is the core of the fukking culture.
The burger in hamburger.
Class dismissed....
you yotch.
Yes I AGREE balance is NEEDED, like everyone in this thread has stated. Too much lyricism over flow is bad(i.e Eminem and Hopsin). And too much flow over lyricism is bad(i.e these one hit wonders).
The thing is you're acting like lyricism/rapping is not one of the main focal points of Hip Hop. The very thing that separates Hip Hop from Funk/Soul, R&B, Rock, Pop,etc. This post indirectly agrees with me. How much is Hip Hip different from Funk/Soul without rapping/lyricism??