How Christian McAffrey a 97 in madden and Saquan Barkley only a 90?

[RareHunter]

Other than durability, Saquan is the more exciting back, with better jukes, better cutbacks, better vision, better catching ability(multiple 1 handers), explosive, you name it. Bigger, faster, stronger.

McAffrey easily #2 off the eye test.

 

[BaggerofTea]

McCaffrey went 1k and 1k

 

[RareHunter]

McCaffrey went 1k and 1k

Giants Oline is what’s messin Saquan up. He just to heavy, to consistently have to be Barry Sanders making lateral runs.

 

[BucciMane]

So, you're just going to assume after two injury plagued seasons that Barkley is still faster, has better jokes, and better vision while Cmac has been performing at an all-pro level?.


I'm not even going to say Cmac is better, but the premise of this thread is beyond absurd..

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

McCaffrey body of work>>>>

 

[RareHunter]

So, you're just going to assume after two injury plagued seasons that Barkley is still faster, has better jokes, and better vision while Cmac has been performing at an all-pro level?.


I'm not even going to say Cmac is better, but the premise of this thread is beyond absurd..

CMac was injured to tho.

 

[BucciMane]

CMac was injured to tho.

He's had an elite season though.

I'm not even saying he's the best HB, but I understand the ratings for them.

 

[NatiboyB]

I don’t think it much matters once they start really playing their ratings change

 

[dizzy4111]

Because he's better at concussionball

 

[Keengcong]

Better question is how is King Henry not #1

 

[Pressure]

Because CMC is and always has been better.

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

Because CMC is and always has been better.

Yeah it's not really debatable right now..

 

[BucciMane]

Because CMC is and always has been better.

He's proven himself in the league, whether people want to say he's a volume back for hyped because he's white..

I didn't know what to expect of him, but you can't deny he's been sensational..

 

[El Bombi]

One just tore his ACL.

 

[RareHunter]

He's proven himself in the league, whether people want to say he's a volume back for hyped because he's white..

I didn't know what to expect of him, but you can't deny he's been sensational..

He is a volume back if we keep in it real. Put him on the Giants and he’d be pretty useless. Even prime Zeke would be pedestrian on the Giants.