This should be the lineup until Chandler comes back
Martin
Metta
Anthony
Shumpert
Murry
This is a lineup to set the tone up defensively...Metta still a tough player even at his age who can still stretch the floor with his shooting ability and his ability to drive to the basket. Kenyon is a given for his toughness, able to play smart defense (ie. amare and bargnani should learn from him how to play help defense) and his ability to rebound. Murry is able to keep the opposition in front of him something Felton will never learn to do. And Murry knows how to get in the inside which will only open for easy buckets for Martin down low, Metta in the Corner, Shumpert at behind the arc or Melo 15ft or above. By setting the tone defensively, then your 2nd unit can come in looking like this...
Bargnani
Amare
Jr
Pablo
Udrih
To be quite honest with you, Bargnani and Amare will not work because of spacing on the court.
Knicks will seriously have to look at moving Smith in January when he's able to be moved. The guy I would ove the knicks to acquire is Taj Gibson from Chicago. They are in serious need of a scorer like Smith and we're still lacking depth up front from a rebounding and defensive stand point.