Gotta go by position cause I have no clue how you can compare centers and point guards here.
PG: CP3
SG: Jordan
SF: LeBron
PF: Duncan
Center: Hakeem
Kawhi, Payton, KG, Kareem, Admiral, and Tony Allen all get honorable mention....honestly toss-up with CP3 and Payton, Payton is a significantly better defender while CP3 was far better on offense, same issue with Kawhi and LeBron (especially since both have very short peaks on one side of the ball).
PG: CP3
SG: Jordan
SF: LeBron
PF: Duncan
Center: Hakeem
Kawhi, Payton, KG, Kareem, Admiral, and Tony Allen all get honorable mention....honestly toss-up with CP3 and Payton, Payton is a significantly better defender while CP3 was far better on offense, same issue with Kawhi and LeBron (especially since both have very short peaks on one side of the ball).