2010 Tom Brady Or 2014 Aaron Rodgers?

[Street Knowledge]

Both won MVP, Both led their teams to the Number one scoring offense in the League(Patriots 32.4 PPG/ Packers 30.4 PPG)

2010 Brady

65.9%/3900 Yards/7.9 YPA/36 Touchdowns/4 Interceptions/111 Passer Rating
Patriots 14-2

2014 Rodgers

65.6%/4381 Yards/8.4 YPA/38 Touchdowns/5 Interceptions/112 Passer Rating
Packers 12-4

 

[Remote]

Aaron Rodgers.

He doesn't have a bunch of scandals under his belt like Brady and Belichick do.

Not saying Brady isn't good. But all things being equal, I'll take the guy with less bullshyt around him.

 

[Raquinotj]

Aaron Rodgers.

He doesn't have a bunch of scandals under his belt like Brady and Belichick do.

Not saying Brady isn't good. But all things being equal, I'll take the guy with less bullshyt around him.

4 > 1 I know it burns, Take that scandal.

To answer the OP. 2010 was probably Brady's best Year including his 50 TD Season.

 

[Remote]

4 > 1 I know it burns, Take that scandal.

To answer the OP. 2010 was probably Brady's best Year including his 50 TD Season.

Yeah, Brady has 4 titles.

But let's analyze this a bit.

1. A field goal that barely beat the Rams.
2. The Panthers kicked a ball out of bounds in the 4th quarter.
3. They beat the Eagles by 3 points going against an injured Terrell Owens and a goofball Donovan McNabb.
4. They beat the Seahawks on possibly the worst call in Super Bowl history.

Yeah, he's 4 titles deep, but let's keep it real.

Nobody would say they ever dominated to any of those titles.

 

[Raquinotj]

Yeah, Brady has 4 titles.

But let's analyze this a bit.

1. A field goal that barely beat the Rams.
2. The Panthers kicked a ball out of bounds in the 4th quarter.
3. They beat the Eagles by 3 points going against an injured Terrell Owens and a goofball Donovan McNabb.
4. They beat the Seahawks on possibly the worst call in Super Bowl history.

Yeah, he's 4 titles deep, but let's keep it real.

Nobody would say they ever dominated to any of those titles.

Are you serious? 15 years of Dominance? 12 Division Titles, 9 AFC Championship Games, 6 Super Bowls, 4 Rings, and basically all the Passing/Winning Records in the Playoffs? Couldve, should've would've nikka, you should be thankful for Tyree miracle catch and Wes Welker Drop now that I think about it we're online ordering Super Bowl champion garments. You're online looking at mock drafts. We are not the same. Go Debate your 8th Overall draft Pick.

 

[Tony D'Amato]

Aaron Rodgers is already the goat qb. Fukk whatchu heard. Never seen anybody slang dat thang like ARod

 

[Remote]

Are you serious? Couldve, should've would've nikka, you should be thankful for Tyree miracle catch and Wes Welker Drop now that I think about it we're online ordering Super Bowl champion garments. You're online looking at mock drafts. We are not the same. Go Debate your 8th Overall Pick.

?

I'm a Dolphins fan, breh



But what's right is right.


The Patriots got scandals on their hands, B.
And they eked out every SB win.

It is what it is.
I mean we aren't talking about the 49ers and 55-10.

 

[malbaker86]

4 > 1 I know it burns, Take that scandal.

To answer the OP. 2010 was probably Brady's best Year including his 50 TD Season.

What the hell does 4 SB's have to do with this thread?

Edit: its a toss up but ill take Rodgers this season. No wrong answer btw

 

[Raquinotj]

What the hell does 4 SB's have to do with this thread?

Edit: its a toss up but ill take Rodgers this season. No wrong answer btw

4 SBs has the same to do with this thread as the above mentioned "scandals".

 

[Savior]

Yeah, Brady has 4 titles.

But let's analyze this a bit.

1. A field goal that barely beat the Rams.
2. The Panthers kicked a ball out of bounds in the 4th quarter.
3. They beat the Eagles by 3 points going against an injured Terrell Owens and a goofball Donovan McNabb.
4. They beat the Seahawks on possibly the worst call in Super Bowl history.

Yeah, he's 4 titles deep, but let's keep it real.

Nobody would say they ever dominated to any of those titles.

The same way you can say he's a miracle catch and wes welker dropped pass away from 6 SB's. Plus the last 6/8 SB's were decided by a TD or less. Guess all those have a * too

 

[Spiritual Stratocaster]

4 SBs has the same to do with this thread as the above mentioned "scandals".

You're a shyt poster

Super Bowls have nothing to do with the thread...

My answer is Rodgers though.

 

[Remote]

The same way you can say he's a miracle catch and wes welker dropped pass away from 6 SB's. Plus the last 6/8 SB's were decided by a TD or less. Guess all those have a * too

Decent point.

 

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

Let's stay on topic....

2010 Brady v 2014 Aaron Rodgers

The numbers are too close to really give either an edge. Rodgers lost in the Championship game, Brady lost in the Super Bowl, again too close to call.

I'm gonna give it to Brady on GP, tho

 

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

What the hell does 4 SB's have to do with this thread?

Edit: its a toss up but ill take Rodgers this season. No wrong answer btw

You're a shyt poster

Super Bowls have nothing to do with the thread...

My answer is Rodgers though.

Y'all really gonna act like he wasn't responding to the "scandals" nonsense which has nothing to do with the thread

 

[FAH1223]

Let's stay on topic....

2010 Brady v 2014 Aaron Rodgers

The numbers are too close to really give either an edge. Rodgers lost in the Championship game, Brady lost in the Super Bowl, again too close to call.

I'm gonna give it to Brady on GP, tho

Brady didn't lose in the Super Bowl in 2010, he lost to the Jets in the Divisional Round.

I'm biased but give me Rodgers. His mobility and throws on the run are second to none in the NFL. He played a lot more mature than even his monster 2011 season.