2010 Rodgers over both because he actually won the super bowl. And if you're talking about regular season stats, than I really don't give a shyt because Peyton is the king of the regular season.
Rodgers 2010 playoff run to win the super bowl was the most impressive qb play I've ever seen. The way he sonned Arizona and Atlanta was pure poetry in motion. Granted he did play bad in the nfc championship against the bears, but luckily Jay cutlers fakkit ass quit on his team.
But the super bowl against the steelers was prolly his best performance. There were 3 or 4 deep balls he threw in tight windows where either Polamalu or Ryan Clark milliseconds always from picking it off. no other qb neither Brady or manning could've made those throws.
Rodgers is a streaky qb and when he's hot, he untouchable - Case in point this past midseason when green bay went on a winning streak.
Its just that I was so disappointed that he didn't attack seattle more, especially when earl and Sherman got hurt.
The difference between Tom and Rodgers is: even if Tom throws picks, he doesn't get scared and play conservative. He still attacks because he doesn't want you to give the defense confidence.
....first reply to the thread was dude talking about 4 super bowl wins...
