Gil Scott-Heroin
Veteran
No they weren't elite players.why you think they got together in the first place??
The same shyt could be said for Lebron.

No they weren't elite players.why you think they got together in the first place??

The 04 Pistons were the only team in the history in the league to win a championship without a top 5 player. If you don't have a top 5 player on your team you can forget about winning it all.need for an elite player shyt is a myth. there are only 5 true elite players in this league.
see Detroit Pistons 2004.
nikka are you on crack?@phillycavsfan
I know what an outlier is. You are using the term outlier to validate your point that you need elite players to win championships. It is a fallacy and a convenient way of ignoring that winning a championship without a "elite player" is possible. what about Boston in 08???
@malbaker86
I know but i am saying that "elite players" are a lot more rare than you or the NBA(and the media) got the fans to believe.


I saw the bullshyt you posted. Your reasoning of "An elite player can mask a lot weaknesses on a team and will said team to championship in spite of said weaknesses" is unrealistic and idiotic because there's only ONE player in the league that fits that criteria.
you can't be this stupid. 
By this logic, is Kobe elite? When he was in his prime and didn't have another all star beside him, he lost in the first round twice. When he won his 5th championship against Boston, he didn't will them to a championship. He had a piss poor game and was carried by Metta World Peace of all people.

you can't be this stupid.
so he's not going to win the championship this year??
Tell me what other team is going to beat the Heat this year. And look how those teams are built, come back and make your point .

Kobe can perform at an elite level for a limited period of time but he cannot do it for long stretches of games like he used to. And his defense is just![]()
What happened to him in Cleveland? You said that Allen/Pierce/KG got together because they couldn't win a title individually. The same applies to Lebron; the same currently applies to Wade; the same applies to Bosh.
![]()

BOsh is not an elite player. Wade is. And so is Lebron.
what did KG/Pierce/Allen do before they got together???
what did Wade/Lebron do before they got together?
![]()
game up.BOsh is not an elite player. Wade is. And so is Lebron.
what did KG/Pierce/Allen do before they got together???
what did Wade/Lebron do before they got together?
![]()
@Po pimp
HELL Yea prime Kobe was an elite player. Or did you forget that the Lakers became an instant contender the moment Bynum just elevated his play in 08???
Bynum was better in 08 than Pau was. We were the number 1 seed in the West before he went down with an injury.Really? I thought the Pau Gasol trade had more to do with that. By the way, I do think Kobe was elite, but your "elite player" criteria is flawed.
Bynum was better in 08 than Pau was. We were the number 1 seed in the West before he went down with an injury.

whatever I say, you will always come up with some bullshyt that makes no sense.Bynum was better in 08 than Pau was. We were the number 1 seed in the West before he went down with an injury.
Kobe can perform at an elite level for a limited period of time but he cannot do it for long stretches of games like he used to. And his defense is just![]()
Nah Drew was better. His impact on defense alone >>>> anything Pau brought in 2008.no Bynum wasn't better than Pau. Bynum just elevated his play from where it was at the previous year. Pau in 08 was better than Bynum(at the start of the season) and Pau in 08 wasn't a better player than Wade
@Gil Scott-Heroin
I'm not going to argue with you bruh....you are kinda "special"whatever I say, you will always come up with some bullshyt that makes no sense.
Wasn't even first in your division before the trade.

They would have been able to sign Bynum this summer even with Iguodala picking up his option as long as they don't resign Hawes last summer. The real key though, is they would have been able to evaluate Nikola, and monitor Bynum from a distance. I understand why they traded for Bynum, but they had no shot at winning a title with him even if he was healthy. They would have been better off keeping their assets and not taking on Jason Richardson's contract.
You keep saying Nikola isn't a star, but right now neither is BynumAt least you'd have a starting center, and the chance to draft a star player, right now you don't have a center.