I shunned it @ first and never gave it a chance cuz his subject matter is weak, his flows cliche, and his delivery subpar, I just didn't get the appeal. But recently, I gave the album another spin and I gotta say 
Even though it suffers from sequencing issues (its not good enough to be 12 tracks long and it has 2 outro's in Phoenix & Suddenly), the album has something for everybody.
You got experimental tracks like "Wild For The Night", "I Come Apart", and "Fashion Killa" that appeal to his hipster fanbase, the Clams Casino sound with "LVL" and "Hell", the classic A$AP sounds (LongLiveA$AP, Ghetto Symphony, Jodye, Goldie), something for the radio (fukkin' Problems), and something for the hip hop heads (1Train & Suddenly).
A very consistent album overall
Just get rid of like 2 or 3 verses from 1Train
If you feel like he's a shytty rapper, you've got to appreciate the way he rides a beat
He's like Schoolboy Q infused with Danny Brown and a sprinkle of Lil' Wayne
If you're still a critic, I recommend you replay it again in this sequence:
1. Suddenly
2. Jodye
3. LongLiveA$AP
4. Goldie
5. PMW
6. Ghetto Symphony
7. Angels
8. LVL
9. Hell
10. Pain
11. fukkin' Problems
12. 1Train
13. Fashion Killa
14. I Come Apart
15. Phoenix
I bump it up from a 3/5 to a 3.9/5

Even though it suffers from sequencing issues (its not good enough to be 12 tracks long and it has 2 outro's in Phoenix & Suddenly), the album has something for everybody.
You got experimental tracks like "Wild For The Night", "I Come Apart", and "Fashion Killa" that appeal to his hipster fanbase, the Clams Casino sound with "LVL" and "Hell", the classic A$AP sounds (LongLiveA$AP, Ghetto Symphony, Jodye, Goldie), something for the radio (fukkin' Problems), and something for the hip hop heads (1Train & Suddenly).

A very consistent album overall

If you feel like he's a shytty rapper, you've got to appreciate the way he rides a beat

If you're still a critic, I recommend you replay it again in this sequence:
1. Suddenly
2. Jodye
3. LongLiveA$AP
4. Goldie
5. PMW
6. Ghetto Symphony
7. Angels
8. LVL
9. Hell
10. Pain
11. fukkin' Problems
12. 1Train
13. Fashion Killa
14. I Come Apart
15. Phoenix
I bump it up from a 3/5 to a 3.9/5