This isn't about bad or good. It's about what is required of the QB. Teams that are more dependent on their QB fare worse than teams that aren't as dependent. As I pointed out, this is true even with the same QB at different points.
Aaron Rodgers......
- Thread starter Chip Skylark
- Start date
This isn't about bad or good. It's about what is required of the QB. Teams that are more dependent on their QB fare worse than teams that aren't as dependent. As I pointed out, this is true even with the same QB at different points.
xXMASHERXx
Superstar
I already got called a hater for what I said in the thread @murksiderock created. All I will say is that everyone wants to say his defense let him down but ignore that his defense gave him 3 TOs. If they get TDs instead of FGs the game isn't even close. Not saying it's his fault they lost but he does deserve some criticism
Only Kap, Goff, Foles, Jimmy G,Rex Matt, over the last 15 years are not HOF qbs that played in the SB. Only one of them won
I already got called a hater for what I said in the thread @murksiderock created. All I will say is that everyone wants to say his defense let him down but ignore that his defense gave him 3 TOs. If they get TDs instead of FGs the game isn't even close. Not saying it's his fault they lost but he does deserve some criticism
I got called a hater this morning in our fantasy football chat. And I’ve been saying he’s the goat for years over brady and I’ll admit it’s been because of his talent.
I think the point he's going for is that Megamind in his last yr was nowhere near HOF level for example
I forgot Cam to my list. He sucked ass that game too. So It didn’t matter Peyton sucked.
Matty Ice?
Old Manning?
Rookie Wilson?
Flacco?
2x Eli? (Only a HOF QB because of the SB)
Not sure what your point is. BTW Flacco, Hasselback, Grossman, and Cam ain't going to the HOF. Matt's a maybe but no guarantees. Eli only getting in because of those SBs. Big reason for Ben too. Peyton was a straight up ghost in one SB. Russ was a 2nd year, hand off master, certainly not HOF caliber at that point.
You're right, Russ was in his 2nd year but he was not playing at a HOF at that time. That was LOB and them. It doesn't really matter if you're a future HOF.
Eli easily gets into the HOF because of winning 2 SBs vs Brady. Eli really shouldn't be put in the HOF and def should not be called a HOF type QB.
My point is u need a HOF qb to win. So betting the house on one is well worth it
Next year, the Packers will have had 30 straight years with 2 of the best QBs in the history of the NFL and only 3 Superbowl appearances in those 3 decades.
If that doesn't show how the blame's lain at the feet of the franchise, I don't know what to tell you.
If that doesn't show how the blame's lain at the feet of the franchise, I don't know what to tell you.
Ozymandeas
Veteran
Brady is the GOAT...Rodgers is an amazing quarterback but, people need to give it up. Rodgers had three turnovers, he could've converted those and changed the game. He didn't. Also, you could tell from their body language yesterday. The Bucs looked completely in control, like the game was a formality before they could go to the Superbowl whereas Green Bay was just hoping it wasn't a blow out. At least that was how I perceived it watching them. That likely played into the interceptions as Brady was flinging the ball without a care in the world and Rodgers had no errors but, was ultimately playing not to lose (should've went for the touchdown 
).
).