"Alien: Earth" | 2025 | FX Series From Noah Hawley

OJ Simpsom

Superstar
Joined
Dec 6, 2013
Messages
16,280
Reputation
9,858
Daps
44,888
There would be no show.
Yes there would. Its called Alien. They could have still had the eggs and the eye and the fly thing. The eye is the Xeno of this season. End S1 with baby Xeno on the loose and introduce adult Xeno and Weyland in season 2 going against The eye and Prodigy. No one asked for my pet Xeno walking around wearing Adidas in broad day light. They ruined a GOAT monster to make the show campy and Jurassic World like. Typical Disney BS tryna cater to everyone while they shyt on the real fans. Doing to Alien what they did to Star Wars and MCU.
 

The_Sheff

A Thick Sauce N*gga
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
27,013
Reputation
5,503
Daps
125,454
Reppin
ATL to MEM
Yes there would. Its called Alien. They could have still had the eggs and the eye and the fly thing. The eye is the Xeno of this season. End S1 with baby Xeno on the loose and introduce adult Xeno and Weyland in season 2 going against The eye and Prodigy. No one asked for my pet Xeno walking around wearing Adidas in broad day light. They ruined a GOAT monster to make the show campy and Jurassic World like. Typical Disney BS tryna cater to everyone while they shyt on the real fans. Doing to Alien what they did to Star Wars and MCU.

They will never make Alien material without full Xeno's again after Prometheus.
 

TheDarceKnight

Veteran
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
30,755
Reputation
13,861
Daps
96,718
Reppin
Jiu Jitsu
This is all BS. He's from Scotland and isn't even American. Tf do I care if he reviewed Sinners or if he's conservative? You just sound salty breh. His Alien Earth videos are spot on. The show is trash. Yall sound like agents of the coli in here defending Disney BS like they give af about anything but pumping out garbage for retards like you to defend and act like the critics are wrong when they say the writing is absolute trash. Nice try though. You ain't convincing anyone this show isn't trash because one of the people that said it isn't a Liberal or doesn't fukk with Sinners. FOH
First of all WTF does what country he's from have to do with him being a racist or a grifter or not? Is being a grifter limited to being American? Of course not. That's a ridiculous thing to say.

2nd of all...I also don't think this is a good TV show. Where in this thread have I tried to defend this show to anyone?

It's written by morons and stupid choices are pretty much the only thing moving the plot forward. Am I enjoying watching it? Yes. Do I think it's a good show? Absolutely not.

But I can't take The Critical Drinker seriously, because he's an unserious person, and when he's critiques aren't problematic, they're also often just incorrect. He frequently tries to criticize plot points in movies that he doesn't even understand.

My problems aren't with anyone trashing this show, but anytime I see a Critical Drinker vid pop up, I feel obligated to say my piece.
 

TheDarceKnight

Veteran
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
30,755
Reputation
13,861
Daps
96,718
Reppin
Jiu Jitsu
G1Vaq-kWwAAl88H


My Adidas!
:dead: did this shot actually make it into the show?
 

OJ Simpsom

Superstar
Joined
Dec 6, 2013
Messages
16,280
Reputation
9,858
Daps
44,888
First of all WTF does what country he's from have to do with him being a racist or a grifter or not? Is being a grifter limited to being American? Of course not. That's a ridiculous thing to say.

2nd of all...I also don't think this is a good TV show. Where in this thread have I tried to defend this show to anyone?

It's written by morons and stupid choices are pretty much the only thing moving the plot forward. Am I enjoying watching it? Yes. Do I think it's a good show? Absolutely not.

But I can't take The Critical Drinker seriously, because he's an unserious person, and when he's critiques aren't problematic, they're also often just incorrect. He frequently tries to criticize plot points in movies that he doesn't even understand.

My problems aren't with anyone trashing this show, but anytime I see a Critical Drinker vid pop up, I feel obligated to say my piece.
Most podcasters are grifters. Thats the game. And reviews are subjective. If you don't like his videos or his points, that's cool. I'm sure he doesn't take what he does serious since it's comedy based. But saying he's a racist without any proof is just dumb. And not liking someone doesn't automatically mean their opinion on a show is wrong. Most of us agree with the points he was making in that video.
 

TheDarceKnight

Veteran
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
30,755
Reputation
13,861
Daps
96,718
Reppin
Jiu Jitsu
Most podcasters are grifters. Thats the game. And reviews are subjective. If you don't like his videos or his points, that's cool. I'm sure he doesn't take what he does serious since it's comedy based. But saying he's a racist without any proof is just dumb. And not liking someone doesn't automatically mean their opinion on a show is wrong. Most of us agree with the points he was making in that video.
I think there is proof that he's a racist, and I think the proof are in his own words and actions. I find his opinions to frequently be racist. What do you need, a video of him saying "I hate black people"? He's a bigot. Plain and simple.

But we do agree that the show isn't good.

I think anything else re: critical drinker will probably be talking in circles
 

The_Sheff

A Thick Sauce N*gga
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
27,013
Reputation
5,503
Daps
125,454
Reppin
ATL to MEM
I feel bad for Prometheus because it was almost there but that movie got some stupidity too

But David is one of the best things the franchise has ever produced

I agree. I like the tech and gritty future aspect of this franchise I just wish they could explore things outside of the Xeno's and the audience accept it.
 
Top