All Out War: Official Walking Dead Season 8 Thread

Roman Brady

Nobody Lives Forever
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
16,749
Reputation
-1,065
Daps
14,888
I haven't read through this thread but can someone explain to me hayzeus's 180? Its like it was ok to kill ppl until....what the writers realized despite their circumstances we need to have the main character be the beacons of morality? It was so irksome that he suddenly took morgan's role saying" its not what we do". :why: who is you? You just joined the crew. And the hilltop has killed to protect themselves before:why:
 

Soymuscle Mike

Formerly known as Vincenzo Corleone
Supporter
Joined
Jun 6, 2012
Messages
12,340
Reputation
5,413
Daps
61,420
Reppin
Sweetlake City
Gun to my head I wouldn't have recognized Latino dude if y'all wouldn't talk about it.

That shootout was just awful.
 

HiiiPower

Superstar
Joined
Oct 14, 2012
Messages
11,774
Reputation
1,940
Daps
44,000
Reppin
NULL
I haven't read through this thread but can someone explain to me hayzeus's 180? Its like it was ok to kill ppl until....what the writers realized despite their circumstances we need to have the main character be the beacons of morality? It was so irksome that he suddenly took morgan's role saying" its not what we do". :why: who is you? You just joined the crew. And the hilltop has killed to protect themselves before:why:
Nope, just trash writing lol
 

Skeptic

Superstar
Joined
Sep 1, 2015
Messages
6,483
Reputation
1,351
Daps
22,473
So Glen got killed less than two months ago? Maggie isn't showing a baby bump in the slightest and she's thinner than ever.
 

bl2k8

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
29,898
Reputation
3,996
Daps
106,331
Reppin
Northern California
Gun to my head I wouldn't have recognized Latino dude if y'all wouldn't talk about it.

That shootout was just awful.
Writers just trying to throw the diehard fanboys a bone. They’ve been begging for him for a while. I doubt he even last 5 episodes, he makes no sense being there the entire season
 

Soymuscle Mike

Formerly known as Vincenzo Corleone
Supporter
Joined
Jun 6, 2012
Messages
12,340
Reputation
5,413
Daps
61,420
Reppin
Sweetlake City
yeah I don't care about this show anymore. that last episode was atrocious.

still out here tryna :cape: for killers

nah

show is garbage water now.

This "war" really exposes how these dudes have no idea what they're doing. These action scenes are embarrassing. Makes Z-Nation look like Game of Thrones.
 

HiiiPower

Superstar
Joined
Oct 14, 2012
Messages
11,774
Reputation
1,940
Daps
44,000
Reppin
NULL
Took this from another forum, I guess some of them are nitpicky but pretty much valid for the most part.

25 things from the first two episodes of Walking Dead alone that don't make sense, are inconsistent, or just plain horrible.

Episode 1

1. If Negan was the only one that needed to be killed, why not have the sharpshooter that killed the lookouts on the roof take him out as soon as he was on the balcony.

2. Why would Negan stand out on the balcony with no cover knowing he was at war and the main target?

3. How'd not one of them get hit on that balcony under heavy automatic fire?

4. Dwight is working with Rick giving them info and was on that balcony, they obviously didn't care about him (this might be true tbf)

5. Where'd they get all this ammo from to waste when it was limited a season ago.

6. Where were all the saviours and workers inside the sanctuary? They're all willing to die for Negan, not one decided to get out there and help him?

7. There was no need to fire all the bullets to lure the walker herd there when Daryl was already doing it.

8. They're following Daryl and the gunfire anyway, why waste explosives when you're at war.

9. How'd that slow shambling herd get from where they were all the way to the sanctuary over the course of that 1 gunfight? You'd be able to argue that they started that way before Rick arrived, but the saviour patrol car that got blown up with the tripwire happened during Negan and Ricks confrontation since Negan noticed the smoke from it before Rick opened fire.

10. Why on earth Would Gabe try to rescue Gregory? He clearly picked a side, At that point it would be like him trying to rescue Simon.

11. Why would Gabe just not run after Gregory when he was running to the car.

12. Why would Gabe not kill Negan in the trailer since he had a machine gun (tho tbf we still don't know what's going to happen here yet)

Episode 2
13. Why is a whole squad of people trying to catch up to one guy to stop him warning other saviours when it's clear they're at war anyway. These people communicate between outposts with Walkie Talkies.

14. How did the reinforcements Ezekiel sent for turn up in the same place at the same time as them as soon as they found the guy they were after.

15. Why are just Rick and Daryl sneaking into a main outpost for one of the most important missions to steal the saviour guns? while having big squads like Aaron's attack that small outpost.

16. That whole shootout with Aaron's group was choreographed horribly.

17. Again where did all these bullets come from?

18. Why did that female Saviour at this outpost let that slow walker just casually fall on top of her and bite her? She had all the time in the world.

19. Why did Morgan and the other two freeze when they opened the door and saw the saviours inside?

20. Did Morgan get shot? If not why is he just lying there, you could make a case he was playing dead tho.

21. Why does Jesus wanna save them all of a sudden? Especially after that one guy turned out to be a liar and held a gun to his head?

23. This whole confrontation was happening while Tara and Jesus's squad was literally a few steps away in the corridor..and the door was open.

24. We can't hear any gunfire from the shootout in the corridor 5 feet away as this is happening.

25. What is jesus expecting with these saviour hostages? For them to pitch in at the hilltop? They'll kill them all the first chance the Saviours get.
 

marcuz

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
54,995
Reputation
12,865
Daps
157,122
^^ all of these reasons bug me and are boiled down to negan plot armor
 

marcuz

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
54,995
Reputation
12,865
Daps
157,122
small changes in writing could have fixed some of these. like having negan higher than everyone else while hiding behind eugene or something.

maybe have gabe run out of ammo or lose his gun in a struggle.

have a scene where they explain how they got all this ammo. i originally thought they buried their stash in one of the graves.

its still entertaining though. if the spoilers are true, TWD is going in a totally different direction from the comics
 

HiiiPower

Superstar
Joined
Oct 14, 2012
Messages
11,774
Reputation
1,940
Daps
44,000
Reppin
NULL
small changes in writing could have fixed some of these. like having negan higher than everyone else while hiding behind eugene or something.

maybe have gabe run out of ammo or lose his gun in a struggle.

have a scene where they explain how they got all this ammo. i originally thought they buried their stash in one of the graves.

its still entertaining though. if the spoilers are true, TWD is going in a totally different direction from the comics
Yup I still love the show but most of them are so easily avoidable, I dont get it lol.

Iv seen a lot of people say that about the spoilers, I don't know what happens or wanna know but I'm happy that it seems they've killed Off someone big that no one was expecting, best thing they can do at this point is to veer away from the comics. Some of these things they've copied directly from them look fine in a book but don't translate well into live action tv. Picture the whole of the first half of season 9 just being about old man Rick tending to Alexandria :hhh:
 
Top