All-Time Squad for each NFL team...who wins?

Joined
Dec 19, 2017
Messages
17,086
Reputation
5,115
Daps
68,524
Any player on the roster would have needed to play AT LEAST 3 seasons for your team.

A player can appear on multiple rosters if he played 3 (or more) seasons for each of those teams.

You get the best version of the player...when he played for your team. For example, the Niners get Jerry Rice in his early prime/peak while the Raiders would get a much older but still decent version of Rice

Players are judged on their ability, relative to their peers and era. So, a 250 lb HOF lineman from the 1970s would be on equal footing with a similarly dominant 300 lb lineman from the 1990s. That should balance out the recency bias and account for the modern advantages players have.


You can pick up to two coaches for your team; one HC and one assistant. It doesn't matter if both were HC's for your team. You can also leave the coaching spots blank.

Oilers History - belongs to Tennessee Titans

Browns History - belongs to current Browns
 
Joined
Dec 19, 2017
Messages
17,086
Reputation
5,115
Daps
68,524
Cowboys would be hard to beat, many of them would be from the Triplets era .

Hurts me as a Giants fan to say that, but it is what it is.

Staubach/Aikman

Moose

Emmitt/Dorsett/Zeke/Herschel

Irvin/Pearson/Dez/T.O./Hayes/CeeDee

Rayfield Wright/Larry Allen/Travis Frederick/Stepnoski/Tyron Smith/Erik Williams/Zack Martin

Witten/Novacek/Ditka

Randy White/D-Ware/Micah/Charles Haley/Harvey Martin/Too Tall Jones/Bob Lily/Leon Lett/Russell Maryland/Jethro Pugh/LaRoi Glover

Lee Roy Jordan/Bob Breunig/Ken Norton Jr/Chuck Howley/Dexter Coakley

Mel Renfro/Everson Walls/Darren Woodson/Deion/Cliff Harris etc

Dan Bailey & Brandon Aubrey

Tom Landry & Jimmy Johnson

Most balanced team IMO. They would dominate on both sides of the line and can run or pass on anyone.
 

BucciMane

Kristina Schulman Bro
Supporter
Joined
Mar 4, 2015
Messages
35,462
Reputation
-2,516
Daps
78,457
Reppin
The Real Titletown
It's a very good question. I think the way I would go about it is finding the teams that have never had a HOF QB/WR and eliminating them. There are probably a lot of players I'm not even thinking about right now, but my first instinct is to say the 49er's.
 

BucciMane

Kristina Schulman Bro
Supporter
Joined
Mar 4, 2015
Messages
35,462
Reputation
-2,516
Daps
78,457
Reppin
The Real Titletown
I thought about it for a minute, and I think it's clearly the 49er's if a player only needed to play there for three seasons.

Good luck stopping Rice+Owens+Kittle/VD/Jones+Cmac. Then you have Montana/Young at QB. Their DL would be very good as well with Young, Haley, Stubbafield, Smith, Bosa, and some others. They definitely have the LB's as well with Willis+Bowman. The secondary has a HOF player in Ronnie Lott as well.

Again, if we are taking the players at their peak how they played on THOSE teams, then I take the 49er's.
 

BucciMane

Kristina Schulman Bro
Supporter
Joined
Mar 4, 2015
Messages
35,462
Reputation
-2,516
Daps
78,457
Reppin
The Real Titletown
The Chiefs wouldn't be a bad option either.

Mahomes
Kelce/Gonzo/Hill
Holmes/Charles

Derrick Thomas/Berry/Jones/Hali/Allen


That team will have some big home run plays and will have no problem getting to the QB.
 

threattonature

Veteran
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
24,969
Reputation
4,142
Daps
80,885
The Chiefs wouldn't be a bad option either.

Mahomes
Kelce/Gonzo/Hill
Holmes/Charles

Derrick Thomas/Berry/Jones/Hali/Allen


That team will have some big home run plays and will have no problem getting to the QB.
Yeah I was going to bring up the Chiefs but they'd be lacking big time at WR outside of Tyreke. They'd have one of the best returners of all time in Dante Hall. After the last few years now would have a damn near HOF quality OL at every position. Dale Carter and McDuffie as the primary CBs.
 

MushroomX

Packers Stockholder
Supporter
Joined
Aug 17, 2013
Messages
29,489
Reputation
10,179
Daps
123,946
Reppin
Wisconsin
Packers HOF with a mixture of Lombardi and Holmgren

Coach: Vince Lombardi
QB: Brett Favre
RB: Jim Taylor
WR: Don Hutson, Sterling Sharpe
TE: No Hall of Famers
OL: Jim Ringo, Jerry Kramer, Forrest Gregg
DE: Willie Davis, Reggie White
DT: No Hall of Famers
LB: Ray Nitschke, Dave Robinson
CB: Herb Adderley, Charles Woodson
S: Willie Wood, LeRoy Butler
 

FTBS

Superstar
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
20,968
Reputation
3,779
Daps
57,718
Reppin
NULL
Off top without checking...


Boys
9ers
Steelers
Packers
 

Da_Eggman

Coli Legend
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
57,161
Reputation
4,207
Daps
134,327
Reppin
So-Fla
QB Marino
RB Ricky Williams
FB Csonka
WR Tyreek
WR Paul Warfield
WR Mark Duper
WR Mark Clayton
TE Keith Jackson
LT: Richmond Webb
LG: Bob Kuechenberg
C: Jim Langer
RG: Larry Little
RT: Norm Evans
Dwight Stephenson (C)
Jake Long (T)
Keith Sims (G)
Tim Ruddy (C)

Marino would never leave his feet
 
Top