All-Time Squad for each NFL team...who wins?

Mantis Toboggan M.D.

Drink wolf cola
Joined
Mar 18, 2014
Messages
33,164
Reputation
9,989
Daps
110,181
Reppin
Brooklyn
The fact that none of us are saying the Patriots shows how crazy it was that they won 6 rings 🤣.
So many of their big wins were defined by the other teams doing dumb stuff all on their own along with 3 titles in an era where they got caught cheating. The other big thing is 5 of their Super Bowl wins were by somewhere between 3-6 points and another was a game where they scored 13 points. This stuff causes a lot of fans to think about the other team more. That’s my theory anyway.
 

No1

Retired.
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
31,776
Reputation
5,262
Daps
71,972
So many of their big wins were defined by the other teams doing dumb stuff all on their own along with 3 titles in an era where they got caught cheating. The other big thing is 5 of their Super Bowl wins were by somewhere between 3-6 points and another was a game where they scored 13 points. This stuff causes a lot of fans to think about the other team more. That’s my theory anyway.
They were just a team where most of their talent was on the defense. And in the SB - outside of the Rams (both times) they never really put on a masterclass. It’s also what made all their SBs entertaining - there was always the possibility of them losing. They had hall of famers for sure based on resume but if I put together and all time 22 the only players you would consider starting are Brady, Gronk, Moss and Vinatieri. And Patriots Moss wasn’t even prime Moss despite the TDs.
 
Joined
Dec 19, 2017
Messages
17,086
Reputation
5,115
Daps
68,524
I tried thinking of teams outside of franchises that won a lot of chips and Rams, Ravens and Broncos came to mind.
Vikings would be tough too. They got HOFers all over the field.

Imagine Moss & Carter but with Peterson at RB? Moon or Tarkenton would be feasting.
 
Top