Andrew Luck is becoming the most overrated player in the NFL

[MikeBrownsJob]

Rg3> cam > luck > Wilson> geno > keap

Wilson>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>who cares..The rest are either too dumb to slide, don't read playbooks nor defenses and extremely shaky with their accuracy

 

[MAKAVELI25]

RG3 has more pass attempts than Luck and also has a better completion percentage. As a passer, he's still great but the offense is centered around running the ball. How can you say that they don't trust him as a passer? For a long time, the Redskins have always been a run heavy team.

I'm not going to pretend to be a Redskins expert but I have been watching A LOT of your games for the sheer reason that I have Jordan Reed on my fantasy team. Maybe I'm wrong, but I see play situations all the time where it should be a passing play but your OC calls a running one. Maybe they're trying to stick to the run first philosophy, but its just my own opinion that they don't trust him THAT much as a passer

 

[mrken12]

I'm not going to pretend to be a Redskins expert but I have been watching A LOT of your games for the sheer reason that I have Jordan Reed on my fantasy team. Maybe I'm wrong, but I see play situations all the time where it should be a passing play but your OC calls a running one. Maybe they're trying to stick to the run first philosophy, but its just my own opinion that they don't trust him THAT much as a passer

They always stick to the run first philosophy. 49ers do as well and they've been successful with that. But yet no one has really been saying (until recently) that the coach doesn't trust Kaepernick as a passer. I don't see why it's done with RG3 who is #9 in the NFL for passing yards.

 

[MAKAVELI25]

They always stick to the run first philosophy. 49ers do as well and they've been successful with that. But yet no one has really been saying (until recently) that the coach doesn't trust Kaepernick as a passer. I don't see why it's done with RG3 who is #9 in the NFL for passing yards.

I don't think Kaep is all that good RIGHT NOW either. To me Kaep has top 12 potential, RG3 has top 10/7, Russ has top 5, but I could legitimately see Cam or Luck being the best OVERALL Quarterback in the league. Luck's numbers don't tell the whole story IMO

 

[Mr swag]

I don't think Kaep is all that good RIGHT NOW either. To me Kaep has top 12 potential, RG3 has top 10/7, Russ has top 5, but I could legitimately see Cam or Luck being the best OVERALL Quarterback in the league. Luck's numbers don't tell the whole story IMO

these casual fans kill me

If Wilson was on tHe jaugars they would be looking for another QB. Same as keap

Griffin WAS ON THE JAGUARS they just called them redskins instead

 

[GetSomeMoney]

No offense to some dudes on here but many of the talking points I hear about Luck sound like ESPN talking points, why do people see Luck becoming THE BEST in the league? What would make you say that? Because of some lucky comebacks? one of the most important aspect of a QB is accuracy and that's something Lucks lacks, he does remind me of Eli Manning (those Super Bowls have SAVED Eli's career, on a very loaded team for years), and can end up as Sam Bradford (whose Eli without the rings), your accuracy is about what its gonna be by your second year. What's funny is Luck needs to play more like Vince Young/Vick to reach his true potential, staying in that pocket won't work for him in the long run cause accuracy and slightly above average arm strength are not enough alone. And this Luck makes smarter decisions stuff is based on what, cause he's white and appears like he should make smart decisions? This whole notion he does more on offense is based on what, again that's ESPN talk, a lot of these QBs that run the read option are reading the defense hence the reason its called READ option, and again most of the teams don't run that offense as often as they (ESPN) would like you to believe, like one poster pointed out, RG3 has thrown more passes over Luck. Out of all the young passers, I see Luck kind of in the middle of the pack (as of right now). (Don't watch ESPN pregame/sportcenter fellas, that shyt is horrible)

 

[yseJ]

these casual fans kill me

If Wilson was on tHe jaugars they would be looking for another QB. Same as keap

Griffin WAS ON THE JAGUARS they just called them redskins instead

wilson is better than rg3 and kaep.
wilson has that tom brady coolness to him. hes not asked to do a lot, but when he is, he steps up. dude is a stone cold killer. I hate the hags and I hate him by association, but I cannot deny that fact

 

[mrken12]

No offense to some dudes on here but many of the talking points I hear about Luck sound like ESPN talking points, why do people see Luck becoming THE BEST in the league? What would make you say that? Because of some lucky comebacks? one of the most important aspect of a QB is accuracy and that's something Lucks lacks, he does remind me of Eli Manning (those Super Bowls have SAVED Eli's career, on a very loaded team for years), and can end up as Sam Bradford (whose Eli without the rings), your accuracy is about what its gonna be by your second year. What's funny is Luck needs to play more like Vince Young/Vick to reach his true potential, staying in that pocket won't work for him in the long run cause accuracy and slightly above average arm strength are not enough alone. And this Luck makes smarter decisions stuff is based on what, cause he's white and appears like he should make smart decisions? This whole notion he does more on offense is based on what, again that's ESPN talk, a lot of these QBs that run the read option are reading the defense hence the reason its called READ option, and again most of the teams don't run that offense as often as they (ESPN) would like you to believe, like one poster pointed out, RG3 has thrown more passes over Luck. Out of all the young passers, I see Luck kind of in the middle of the pack (as of right now). (Don't watch ESPN pregame/sportcenter fellas, that shyt is horrible)

I agree. A lot of people hyping up Luck haven't really watched the games. He's a good QB no doubt. But last year when people were putting him in the same category as Wilson and RG3, his hype was getting absurd.

 

[Juanito]

 

[MikeBrownsJob]

 

[Tony D'Amato]

He's hasnt got better brehs

 

[Biscayne]

How is he the most overrated? He hardly gets mentioned b/c Kaep, Russ & Jimmy Crack Corn III are always on tv. He's not perfect, but he's on pace to be a top 10 level QB by the end of the year

I know the OP is a bi polar, hypersensitive fan who loves a player & then hates him the next day, but Luck's a beast

2yrs later, can you say the same?

 

[Maschine_Man]

What's funny is that Tannehill is going to go down as the best QB from this draft.

 

[ROFL_GUY]

wilson is better than rg3 and kaep.
wilson has that tom brady coolness to him. hes not asked to do a lot, but when he is, he steps up. dude is a stone cold killer. I hate the hags and I hate him by association, but I cannot deny that fact

truth

 

[TrebleMan]

I will say he benefits from playing in a real weak division.

In two years I think Mariota will be the best QB in the AFC South from there.