If hes healthy i would take RG3 clearly, much more accurate and less turnover prone. 2 of the top 3 things I value most from QB's. And he's more mobile
Andrew Luck vs. RG3: A Year Later, Who You Got?
- Thread starter Snitchin Splatter
- Start date
Congressman Ray Syst Jr.
Banned
A "Healthy RG3" is a oxymoron at this point.
But he can shuck and jive with the best of them
Keep Tap Dancin for Massa Robert
That boy Luck got all the intangibles RG3 lacks, so he's the clear winner
But he can shuck and jive with the best of them
Keep Tap Dancin for Massa RobertThat boy Luck got all the intangibles RG3 lacks, so he's the clear winner
russell wilson
RGIII has a superstar running back in alfred morris tho... which luck doesnt have
In a ranking of Kap, Russell, Luck and RG3.
Im going Russell > Kap > Luck > RG3
RGIII made Alfred Morris. You really think a fukkin 6th round pick could run for 1600 yards without the RGIII option threat?
the rankings go: RGIII = Kaep > Russ > Cam >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Luck
they both work off each other. RG3 aint shyt w/o alfred and alfred and shyt without RG3RGIII made Alfred Morris. You really think a fukkin 6th round pick could run for 1600 yards without the RGIII option threat?
the rankings go: RGIII = Kaep > Russ > Cam >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Luck
thats funny because Luck passed for more yards and touchdowns, as a passer
Luck had 23 TDs with 627 attempts.
RG3 had 20 TDs with 393 attempts.
Also Griffin had a third of the number of interceptions. That efficiency.
And let's not even compare QB ratings.
USSInsiders
Banned
False. RGIII won the Heisman and was the #2 overall pick without Alfred. Morris wasn't shyt but a 6th round pick without RGIII. Stop making up duck tales. RGIII made that whole Skins season by hisself.
Snitchin Splatter
Working With The Feds
Luck had 23 TDs with 627 attempts.
RG3 had 20 TDs with 393 attempts.
Also Griffin had a third of the number of interceptions. That efficiency.
And let's not even compare QB ratings.
So it's Lucks fault RG3's coaches didn't let him throw the ball?
Can't blame luck for producing more yards, touchdowns, and wins
shanahan will always run the ball, probably more this yearSo it's Lucks fault RG3's coaches didn't let him throw the ball?
Can't blame luck for producing more yards, touchdowns, and wins
So it's Lucks fault RG3's coaches didn't let him throw the ball?
Can't blame luck for producing more yards, touchdowns, and wins
More wins in a garbage division. And did you see his QB rating? 76.5.
He only had 3 more touchdowns.
With that being said, Luck is no scrub but RG3 overall is the more efficient player with fewer mistakes.
Snitchin Splatter
Working With The Feds
More wins in a garbage division. And did you see his QB rating? 76.5.
He only had 3 more touchdowns.
With that being said, Luck is no scrub but RG3 overall is the more efficient player with fewer mistakes.
I see where you are going, but I would argue RG3 made "fewer mistakes" because he was asked to do A LOT less
Luck had almost as many completions a RG3 had total passes. It seems like he had more mistakes because he had a lot more responsibility in the offense than RG3 had, in turn he produced more.
That's true. Can't deny that. Luck had a non-existent run game so most of the offensive responsibility was on his shoulders.
Looking at his numbers, for a rookie to have that much responsibility it makes sense that he would have a lot of interceptions and a below average QB rating.