Are we ready to admit that Sonic the Hedgehog doesn't work in 3D and never will?

[Fatboi1]

Sonic adventure sucked

 

[AquaCityBoy]

But the alternative is another Sonic 4

 

[Yuzo]

Knuckles now:

are the new sonic games like this being designed by asians or whites?

 

[Kuwaiti_dude]

we acting like sonic generations was bad now?

 

[Kingshango]

we acting like sonic generations was bad now?

The only dope Sonic game since the Genesis era imo.


The final boss sucked ass tho.

 

[MewTwo]

 

[duncanthetall]

Yeah it doesn't work in 3d. It ends up practically being an on rails type game. You're just moving forward with minimal impact on where you go besides having the ability to jump.

I've always hated the homing ability they added in the 3d games too. shyts dumb

 

[Rice N Beans]

They just need the Nintendo guidance.

 

[Dominic Brehetto]

After dreamcast sega lost their touch as a studio.

Dreamcast they went out wuth a bang though. So many great fukking games. So much creativity.

A sonic game could work.

I bet you anything in the world if nintendo had the sonic ip and gave it the same teams making mario games they would release some incredible games.

 

[illadope]

Sonic Generations was dope as hell and so were the Sonic Adventure titles. They just need to make that formula & drop consistent titles without trying to change up whatever it is they are trying to do.

 

[BasedPrime]

Fukk Sonic. MS needs too buy Jazz Jackrabbit

 

[Prince Luchini]

Yeah I don't know what some of y'all are taking about but the adventure games were dope as fukk. They haven't aged all that well but they're still great games. I think sega just didn't expand on these games formula and perfect them. Every time they make something great they just jump to the next idea.

Colors and generations were great and lost world had some interesting concepts but it wasn't fully thought out yet. Plus they shyt out a new sonic game every year so sega barely have enough time to fully finish them shyts.

 

[winb83]

They should just pack it up, sell Sonic to Nintendo and get it over with

Could Nintendo make a 3D Sonic that works though? Fast moving 3D platforming is a ideal that contradicts itself and becomes too difficult for the player to execute properly. You almost have to automate the movement to make it work.

 

[-DMP-]

Sonic Adventure 2 was dope. Super Sonice and Hyper Shadow.

Grinding on rails

I need that back. I bought a dream cast JUST for that game. Sold it later on for the GAWDSTATION 2

-DMP-

 

[MeachTheMonster]

Could Nintendo make a 3D Sonic that works though? Fast moving 3D platforming is a ideal that contradicts itself and becomes too difficult for the player to execute properly. You almost have to automate the movement to make it work.

I think it could work if they approached it more like a mirrors edge type of game. It could be slowed down a bit and have sonic interact with the environment/obsitcles better.

They keep going with those lose controls where sonic is more like a pinball bouncing around tge environment as opposed truly being a part of it.