As a Bron Stan...

THE MACHINE

night owl
Joined
May 27, 2012
Messages
26,877
Reputation
6,530
Daps
104,366
Reppin
P.G. County
Jerry has been to 8 though. I notice you wont dare address the competiton on the way to the finals.
They have to be tied with rings with the same amount of fMVPs before you consider the other appearances.

2 rings nullifies Jerry Wests 1.
Everything counts when all things are equal at the top. I have no problem counting paths to the finals. Or what role the person was on the team, lead dog, robin or role player. I think that's fair.
 

Kobes Two Jerseys

8 or 24 best player of the era
Joined
May 19, 2012
Messages
9,462
Reputation
1,350
Daps
23,932
Reppin
Fistful of jewels
They have to be tied with rings with the same amount of fMVPs before you consider the other appearances.

2 rings nullifies Jerry Wests 1.
Everything counts when all things are equal at the top. I have no problem counting paths to the finals. Or what role the person was on the team, lead dog, robin or role player. I think that's fair.
Then you need to have a talk with bron stans. 3-5 or 3-6 does not make a goat, top 2, top 3 or top 5 player.
 

THE MACHINE

night owl
Joined
May 27, 2012
Messages
26,877
Reputation
6,530
Daps
104,366
Reppin
P.G. County
Then you need to have a talk with bron stans. 3-5 or 3-6 does not make a goat, top 2 top, 3 or top 5 player.
That's where he is though.

I thought we were just talking about Finals resume. There is more to making a GOAT than Finals resume but it is a major factor. I don't see Bron eclipsing Mike, he would need to beat this year's Warriors for me to consider it. I would put him at 1b if he pulled that off.

4 rings 4 fMVPs 4 reg MVPs
Rings with two different franchises, two different coaches.
30k 8k 8k on 50% shooting
 

Kobes Two Jerseys

8 or 24 best player of the era
Joined
May 19, 2012
Messages
9,462
Reputation
1,350
Daps
23,932
Reppin
Fistful of jewels
That's where he is though.

I thought we were just talking about Finals resume. There is more to making a GOAT than Finals resume but it is a major factor. I don't see Bron eclipsing Mike, he would need to beat this year's Warriors for me to consider it. I would put him at 1b if he pulled that off.

4 rings 4 fMVPs 4 reg MVPs
Rings with two different franchises, two different coaches.
30k 8k 8k on 50% shooting
And 5 losses. I see at least five players better.
 
Top