Basically, This is how the Jay-Z vs Nas debate goes when it comes to albums

[malbaker86]

Illmatic > Reasonable Doubt
It Was Written > In My Life Time
I Am = Vol 2
Nastradamus < Vol 3
QB's Finest < Roc La Familia
Stillmatic > The Brueprint
Street's Disciple > Blueprint 2
God's Son = The Black Album
Hip hop is Dead > Kingdom Come
****** = American Gangster
Life is Good > Blueprint 3
Distant Relatives > Watch the Throne

Fixed

 

[malbaker86]

Let me put a spin on this:

Nas BAD albums(4):
I AM
Nastradamus
QB Finest
Street's Disciple

Jayz BAD albums (5):
In my lifetime
Vol3
Blueprint 2
Kingdom Come
Blueprint 3

I Am and Vol 1 are BAD albums

 

[malbaker86]

And you can't include WTT and Distant Relatives in the argument and not include Best Of Both Worlds 1 and 2?

then you'd have to include The Firm and Lost Tapes right??

 

[JYoung24]

stillmatic>blueprint easily and untitled>american gangster easily

 

[Ohene]

Illmatic = Reasonable Doubt
It Was Written > In My Life Time
I Am > Vol 2
Nastradamus < Vol 3
QB's Finest < Roc La Familia
Stillmatic < The Brueprint
Street's Disciple < Blueprint 2
God's Son = The Black Album
Hip hop is Dead > Kingdom Come
****** < American Gangster
Life is Good > Blueprint 3
Distant Relatives > Watch the Throne

a tie

youz a damn lie

Vol 2 > I Am
The Black Album >>> Gods Son
\Watch the Throne >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Distant relative

 

[Ohene]

Illmatic < Reasonable Doubt
It Was Written > In My Life Time
I Am < Vol 2
Nastradamus < Vol 3
QB's Finest < Roc La Familia
Stillmatic < The Brueprint
Street's Disciple < Blueprint 2
God's Son < The Black Album
Hip hop is Dead > Kingdom Come
****** < American Gangster
Life is Good = Blueprint 3
Distant Relatives < Watch the Throne

most accurate depiction

 

[bigbadbossup2012]

nah
illmatic > reasonable doubt easily

hell naw rd is better

 

[bigbadbossup2012]

Illmatic < Reasonable Doubt
It Was Written > In My Life Time
I Am = Vol 2
Nastradamus < Vol 3
QB's Finest < Roc La Familia
Stillmatic = The Brueprint
Street's Disciple < Blueprint 2
God's Son < The Black Album
Hip hop is Dead > Kingdom Come
****** < American Gangster
Life is Good > Blueprint 3
Distant Relatives = Watch the Throne

my opinion

 

[JayBaldacci]

illmatic=rd
iww > v1
iam = v2
nastradamus = v3
qb = la fam
stillmatic = the bp
the black album > god's son
ss = bp2
hhid > kk
american ganster > untitled
distant relatives = wtt
lig > bp3

 

[jerzboy]

fixed

I agree with them all...........Except QB's Finest... I think that album is better than that "Dynasty" album.... QB's Finest is slept on man... This was after Nas had dropped "Nastradamus" and he was spitting some shyt on this album to let folks know he still had it...

 

[prophecypro]

I think the albums are more close than most people say. Like I dont think its Illmatic and then dissappointing trash vs Every Classic album of the year from Jay.

Personally I find them both even but that's me

 

[L. Deezy]

nah
illmatic > reasonable doubt easily

naw, its a tie to me

I can listen to both those albums and be

 

[@ReallyReal]

wow.....this is pretty good.....now this is how a war is waged......

My fellow Coli brethens i have never seen a thread that compared the body of work of these two artist in its complete form..i will take time out today to listen to all these albums

 

[Pretty Boy]

I;m a big Jay fan but the albums even up.

 

[MINT]

illamtic > rd