I think Pierce is the better overall player. Dirk has had a slightly better career, their careers are almost even.
Carter has to settle for third.
You must be stupid. Dirk is probably the GOAT mid-range shooter next to MJ, is probably the closest we've had to an unguardable shot since the skyhook, and can affect the game without scoring a single point due to his spacing ability and passing.
Dirk is also 13th on the all time scoring list compared to Pierce's 19th, he consistently steps his game up in the playoffs, led his team to a ring in an absurdly good playoff season in 2011, had two 60+ win seasons, and is just the all around more impactful player.
I'm considering hitting you with that neg off of the strength of this stupidity. You better post some decent stats to back up your claim.