Beth Phoenix a HOF'er?

NOSaintsFan02

Superstar
Joined
Jun 4, 2012
Messages
12,626
Reputation
2,002
Daps
56,730

NOSaintsFan02

Superstar
Joined
Jun 4, 2012
Messages
12,626
Reputation
2,002
Daps
56,730
Sable, Ivory, Molly, Mickie, Should go in first.

Beth wasnt even around that long if i recall correctly
See your list though isn't even that good.

At what point does it stop being a Hall of Fame and start being wrestlers who had decent to good runs?

I agree Sable is a HOF for the impact she had. But Ivory? What true impact did she have to call her a HOF'er? She was very talented. A great women's wrestler. That shouldn't make someone an automatic HOF'er though. Same for Mickie and dare I even say Molly. I mean end of the day its WWE HOF so it's nothing to lose sleep over but I would like to think you should have had to really had made an impact of significance to be considered a legend.
 

boriquaking

In Sauce We Trust!
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
13,881
Reputation
3,695
Daps
34,698
Reppin
Big Gete Star
See your list though isn't even that good.

At what point does it stop being a Hall of Fame and start being wrestlers who had decent to good runs?

I agree Sable is a HOF for the impact she had. But Ivory? What true impact did she have to call her a HOF'er? She was very talented. A great women's wrestler. That shouldn't make someone an automatic HOF'er though. Same for Mickie and dare I even say Molly. I mean end of the day its WWE HOF so it's nothing to lose sleep over but I would like to think you had to really had made an impact of significance to be considered a legend.
Im not saying let anyone in, but in my opinion the names i mentioned have had a larger, or sometimes longer impact than Beth.

If it were up to me i'd have Victoria inducted next ahead of all these bytches :francis:
 

Golayitdown

Veteran
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
24,591
Reputation
5,028
Daps
83,353
See your list though isn't even that good.

At what point does it stop being a Hall of Fame and start being wrestlers who had decent to good runs?


I agree Sable is a HOF for the impact she had. But Ivory? What true impact did she have to call her a HOF'er? She was very talented. A great women's wrestler. That shouldn't make someone an automatic HOF'er though. Same for Mickie and dare I even say Molly. I mean end of the day its WWE HOF so it's nothing to lose sleep over but I would like to think you had to really had made an impact of significance to be considered a legend.

In about 5-6 years that's all they're gonna have. They blew their list of names too fast with some of the classes who went in.

On topic, I love Beth. Not too mad for her going in, but there is a nice sized list of women she should go in after. Hell the woman they patterned her after isn't even in yet.
 
Last edited:

mrken12

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Apr 16, 2013
Messages
80,804
Reputation
20,910
Daps
300,354
Reppin
Maryland
See your list though isn't even that good.

At what point does it stop being a Hall of Fame and start being wrestlers who had decent to good runs?

I agree Sable is a HOF for the impact she had. But Ivory? What true impact did she have to call her a HOF'er? She was very talented. A great women's wrestler. That shouldn't make someone an automatic HOF'er though. Same for Mickie and dare I even say Molly. I mean end of the day its WWE HOF so it's nothing to lose sleep over but I would like to think you should have had to really had made an impact of significance to be considered a legend.

They put Rikishi in there. :yeshrug: You know their HOF puts in just about anyone. They put Drew Carey in the Celeb HOF because of ONE appearance. :mjlol:

But still haven't put Cyndi Lauper in there yet or Andy Kaufman. :dwillhuh:
 

Green Ranger

I Am Legend
Joined
May 24, 2012
Messages
29,743
Reputation
2,296
Daps
67,061
Reppin
Angel Grove California
Well now since there dead set on putting a women in each year now there are bound to be a few years where they are going to have to reach. Molly, Victoria, Jazz, Ivory, Mickie, Sable, Chyna should all be in and would be a better choice then Beth.

Not saying Beth shouldn't get in but she should have to wait a lot longer.:francis:Kelly Kelly & Candace Michele getting that HOF nod in a few years at this rate with how there putting women in.

Eve Torres & Mrs Taker Michele McCool should be going in as well very soon.

AJ Lee with the whole Punk situation isn't going in til hell freeze over.
 
Last edited:

Dreamzeedream

Banned
Joined
Dec 9, 2012
Messages
12,098
Reputation
-1,176
Daps
15,298
Reppin
NULL
Well now since there dead set on putting a women in each year now there are bound to be a few years where they are going to have to reach. Molly, Victoria, Jazz, Ivory, Mickie, Sable, Chyna should all be in and would be better choice then Beth.

Not saying Beth shouldn't get in but she should have to wait a lot longer.:francis:Kelly Kelly & Candace Michele getting that HOF nod in a few years at this rate with how there putting women in.

Eve Torres & Mrs Taker Michele McCool should be going in as well very soon.

AJ Lee with the whole Punk situation isn't going in til hell freeze over.

An Wasn't Around that long either
 
Top