Better Debut Album: It’s Dark and Hell is Hot or Reasonable Doubt?
- Thread starter Conscious Pilot
- Start date
This subs gimmick has gotten old at this point
Why's that a surprise? It was recognized as an instant classic that changed the direction of East Coast hip hop
RD was seen as a very dope album but was overlooked for years and had minimal impact. It took years of lobbying by Jay and his fans for RS to reach "consensus classic" status
Mastamimd
Ain't shyt
I don't get how nikkas are surprised...they must have not been there. Both are of equal quality
$cam-U-Well_Jack$on
Superstar
IDAHIH.
Take It In Blood
Banned
One album changed the entire hip-hop game and made brehs throw away their shiny suits
The other was only big in the tri state area
The other was only big in the tri state area
spliz
SplizThaDon
- Joined
- May 2, 2012
- Messages
- 67,178
- Reputation
- 11,159
- Daps
- 224,870
- Reppin
- NY all day..Da Stead & BK..
This is a really wack way of describing IDAHIH. shyt got like 2 club anthems the whole album, IDAHIH had more creativity. It had a crazy vibe to it. It had better and more creative storytelling. It introduced a new sound. It was much more than club anthems. shyt was a dark album actually.
spliz
SplizThaDon
- Joined
- May 2, 2012
- Messages
- 67,178
- Reputation
- 11,159
- Daps
- 224,870
- Reppin
- NY all day..Da Stead & BK..
We’re u actually there when these albums dropped?
So is it based on sales or quality?
Trot LaRoc
Superstar
I love Jay and preferred RD for years. I wasnt big into X in the 90s bc i didnt think he was lyrical enough.
I revisited Dark in recent years and yea....it was a more impactful album and X was a better rhymer thsn i gave him credit for, solid storyteller too
Dark might be a top 5 debut album ever
I revisited Dark in recent years and yea....it was a more impactful album and X was a better rhymer thsn i gave him credit for, solid storyteller too
Dark might be a top 5 debut album ever
