JermaineTR
O.G.
fukk a breh its bruh
Beyonce is the GOAT brehs
- Thread starter Malcolmxxx_23
- Start date
MoneyBags
Dapper Don Don Boss of Bosses Chief of Chiefs
smh, beyonce the most talked about thing on a hip hop message board. never thought I'd see the day.
Ehhh problem with saying 'GOAT' is its such a broad title that you will never reach consensus on it.
Beyonce got a great 20 year record of hits and such, but in terms of GOAT status her music is not really considered 'elite' quality. No offense, its just not widely considered 'genre' defining, or innovative, or the epitome of a genre. In terms of cultural impact of a pure 'performer' she isnt anywhere near an elvis or a micheal jackson or a jame brown. I mean keeping it real honest she isnt even the absolute TOP current R&B 'performer'/mega star with longevity, your boy justin timberlake is probably bigger, probably has more hits, probably has a longer career of hits, and probably has more critical acclaim for his albums...
Female wise in that category she doesnt have much competition... but probably madonna outclasses her just in pure 'performer' status, probably Cher, Dolly Parton, Lianne Rhimes, Reba Macintire, Shania Twain, Loretta Lynn etc are in the same ballpark as her in the pop performer lane. meaning long careers with a lot of records sold that...
Large part of why Beyonce is where she is at as far as 'GOAT'-ness is that R&B female performers arent marketed for long term careers the way country female stars are...
Beyonce got a great 20 year record of hits and such, but in terms of GOAT status her music is not really considered 'elite' quality. No offense, its just not widely considered 'genre' defining, or innovative, or the epitome of a genre. In terms of cultural impact of a pure 'performer' she isnt anywhere near an elvis or a micheal jackson or a jame brown. I mean keeping it real honest she isnt even the absolute TOP current R&B 'performer'/mega star with longevity, your boy justin timberlake is probably bigger, probably has more hits, probably has a longer career of hits, and probably has more critical acclaim for his albums...
Female wise in that category she doesnt have much competition... but probably madonna outclasses her just in pure 'performer' status, probably Cher, Dolly Parton, Lianne Rhimes, Reba Macintire, Shania Twain, Loretta Lynn etc are in the same ballpark as her in the pop performer lane. meaning long careers with a lot of records sold that...
Large part of why Beyonce is where she is at as far as 'GOAT'-ness is that R&B female performers arent marketed for long term careers the way country female stars are...
vaudevillevillain
All Star
i'm sure nobody in their right mind would put beyonce over mike
Rapmastermind
Superstar
Mariah, Whitney, Janet and Sade = Better Catalog's than Beyonce
Janet = Better Dancer and Performer
Mariah, Whitney and Sade = Better voice than Beyonce.
Janet = Better Dancer and Performer
Mariah, Whitney and Sade = Better voice than Beyonce.
MooseMouthMthafuga
Veteran
I don't get it...she's high effort, but nothing special IMO.She puts a lot of effort into pleasing her fans, but as far as being some kind of captivating stage performer, I don't see it.She doesn't have that kind of charisma
Whitney Houston, Patti Labelle, and Gladys Knight's showmanship/holding a note live>>>Beyonce on stage jumping around like a demon possessed Shakira.
The music industry don't care about real talent anymore, so she really has no comp these days.
Her competition/ backdrop is nothing but a bunch of airhead/sex bot bimbos.
Like I said before, She's the queen.....queen of the sophisticated hoodrats
Whitney Houston, Patti Labelle, and Gladys Knight's showmanship/holding a note live>>>Beyonce on stage jumping around like a demon possessed Shakira.
The music industry don't care about real talent anymore, so she really has no comp these days.
Her competition/ backdrop is nothing but a bunch of airhead/sex bot bimbos.
Like I said before, She's the queen.....queen of the sophisticated hoodrats
she's up there.
I_Got_Da_Burna
Superstar
nope. beyonce ain't got shyt on prime aretha, tina turner and winney hutton
010101
C L O N E*0690//////
Jay shoulda never stamped shawty in the game
Jigga man domesticated and his broad is wearing the crown
But feminism got fukk boys sitting back screaming go grrrllll
BOW DOWN bytchES FRFR
JAHAHAHAA//////
Jigga man domesticated and his broad is wearing the crown
But feminism got fukk boys sitting back screaming go grrrllll
BOW DOWN bytchES FRFR
JAHAHAHAA//////
Mike Otherz
All Star
beyonce was official before jay lol. i dont really know what they gave eachother to be honest. i dint think she helped him that much or him helped her. she was the lead singer of the biggest girl group so going solo was an obvious move. shyt, she was basicaly a young diana ross waiting to blow.
and jay was always the laid back rapper making power moves. i dont see how she helped him either. if neither were in each others lives i dont see their careers being much different.
Kill Dat Noize
Banned
beyonce was official before jay lol. i dont really know what they gave eachother to be honest. i dint think she helped him that much or him helped her. she was the lead singer of the biggest girl group so going solo was an obvious move. shyt, she was basicaly a young diana ross waiting to blow.
and jay was always the laid back rapper making power moves. i dont see how she helped him either. if neither were in each others lives i dont see their careers being much different.
i once read somewhere that "he gave her street cred, she gave him class".
pretty on point if you ask me.
010101
C L O N E*0690//////
BEY minus JAY is still a success just not what we are seeing now//////