The fukk? Evans and Godwin have been banged up all year, and they only added AB a few weeks ago. And you're going by reputation too much. Evans and Godwin (especially Evans) have route running issues, which is huge. Playcalling is also ass - compare the playbook and schemes the Chiefs and Rams have to the Buccaneers. Yes, Brady has been inconsistent. No excuses there. But we'll see if they let him call the plays if things can change. Belichick however, you're being soft with. Joe Judge has done virtually the same thing the Patriots have done with the Giants (take a below average team to 4-5 wins, with a bunch of very close losses. Belichick is the GM too, so it's kinda his fault why they have zero talent.