Black Capitalism Won’t Save Us

Benefited

Banned
Joined
Mar 11, 2015
Messages
10,786
Reputation
46
Daps
30,229
Both sides have a point, both those seeking success within this capitalist system, as well as those calling for America to pay the debt it owes us. I hate that this article frames these two positions as mutually exclusive though, as if it's wrong to paper chase and trying to slick diss Jay, Mike, and even Nipsey. You can be a Black entrepreneur, investor, realtor, property owner, etc., and still argue for reparations and justice.

https://www.thecoli.com/threads/let...n-wants-you-to-win-secretly-natureboy.692139/

How about neither side have a point in the long run,both will lead black people to ruin:respect:.. I keep telling yall Nature Boy is one of the greatest minds/speakers of this era,but they would rather listen to speakers who seek assimilation. Every black man should hear this.

"The reason they make it so hard for you,because its in gods plan that you don't become them":wow:(timestamped)



What he says about Jay-z and them is correct also. I understand the need for money to get free and rebuild and seperate,but thats not what most preach. That should be preached first so people can understand how they should look at money.
 

Benefited

Banned
Joined
Mar 11, 2015
Messages
10,786
Reputation
46
Daps
30,229
"You ain't get it the way the jews got it but you already got it,they gave it to you already,and you still ain't happy and won't ever be happy because that ain't whats going to fulfill your soul"-Natureboy


Shows are power as a people we were able to manifest what we have now,from being slaves 100 years ago. Repeating the same sins that got us put in shackles in the first place. We jumped right back in because we just don't seem to get it,biblical history tells us that as the chosen people we are habitual line steppers:respect: We just don't seem to get it,I pray one day we finally get it right and reject the indoctrination and assimilation.
 

Crude Abolitionist

End Slavery
Supporter
Joined
Feb 16, 2017
Messages
17,716
Reputation
2,425
Daps
82,962
Battered by higher insurance prices, hammered by stingy investors, pummeled by exclusive supply chains, assaulted by recessions, thrashed by exclusionary regulators, pounded by an intergenerational wealth gap, a hobbled community of marginal black worker-entrepreneurs must compete with American monopolies and oligopolies like Amazon and Walmart, flush with cash and bolstered by lobbyists. The upshot is predictable. Because they are so wounded by the financial pressures that discrimination exerts, black businesses often can offer only fewer locations, higher prices, and fewer choices. Killer Mike’s consumerism flounders under the racialized reality that black communities have been pushed down for too long to pull themselves up by their bootstraps

In her book The Color of Money: Black Banks and the Racial Wealth Gap, Baradaran explains how the program was innovated in Richard Nixon’s administration. As he took office in 1968, black Americans reeled from generations of discrimination. Instead of mobilizing the large federal government response needed to quell racial inequality through reparations or targeted anti-poverty programs, the president nimbly “co-opted the black power movement’s rhetoric of economic self-determination to push a segregated black economy, thereby justifying his neglect of other proposals for meaningful reform.”

This program was black capitalism—a series of meager tax breaks and incentives touted as enabling a black entrepreneurship that would supposedly redress generations of racialized American plunder. It was a farce—a decoy made of Styrofoam and plastic. But its minuscule price tag and rhetorical appeal made it a political masterstroke that grew into the go-to policy for American presidents.

“Carter did it, Reagan did it, Clinton did it, Obama did it, [and] Trump is doing it now with Opportunity Zones,” Baradaran told me. “Opportunity Zones is black capitalism. It’s been denuded of the word ‘black,’ but it’s essentially the same idea.”

“We’re pretending like we’re helping distressed communities through capital, but it’s actually not capital for the communities themselves. It is development incentives. It is rich private-equity firms and hedge funds getting tax incentives to do stuff, build stuff, and to create stuff in these distressed communities. They get the upside, and they’re protected from the downside because they are going to get tax credits. That is an extension of Nixon’s brilliant decoy,” she continued.

“It looks like we’re helping, but we’re actually not,” Baradaran said. “All it does is prop up a few black businesses to sort of allow for the segregated market to continue breeding inequality.”

By all means keep on ignoring the truth and data tho...
 

Crude Abolitionist

End Slavery
Supporter
Joined
Feb 16, 2017
Messages
17,716
Reputation
2,425
Daps
82,962
For decades, programs providing tax breaks and incentives to a few high-profile black entrepreneurs have sucked all the air out of policy conversations addressing racial economic inequality. These dialogues focused on upper-middle-class black entrepreneurs obscure the plight of everyday black folks living in segregated areas. They ignore poor and working-class people, who need direct investment the most. For example, when publications like Complex run stories describing Nipsey’s Opportunity Zone funds as the “Economic Version of Black Lives Matter,” they miss the point. Black Lives Matter—a movement focused on radical redistributive policy for all black peopleis the economic version of Black Lives Matter.

And if history serves as our guide, it can be profoundly counterproductive to support economic-justice agenda premised on the altruism of black entrepreneurs. Because as NDB Connolly, a Johns Hopkins historian, notes, black entrepreneurs are capable of inflicting the same racialized inequality seen in the broader American economy as anyone else.

“It’s always very funny to me, to hear people celebrate black capitalism, as if somehow the ‘black’ part is supposed to erase the ‘capitalism’ part of it,” he says.


This is not easy to hear but you can't run away from the truth.
 

Crude Abolitionist

End Slavery
Supporter
Joined
Feb 16, 2017
Messages
17,716
Reputation
2,425
Daps
82,962
Looks like this article gave me a new book to read.

51-WqJVi8uL._SX329_BO1,204,203,200_.jpg


Not afraid of the data.

Gotta face the truth head on to solve the issue.

Reparations is needed a debt is owed.
 

yyy

All Star
Joined
Jan 27, 2015
Messages
990
Reputation
1,125
Daps
4,809
I've been meaning to read this article for a while now, so thank you for posting. I'll start by saying that it's a good article. The writer tackles a very difficult subject well. With that being said, the author fundamentally misrepresents both Malcolm X's argument and the argument that many people that believe in Black capitalism make.

On a side note, I find it interesting that Aaron Ross Coleman calls out Malcolm X, but ignores another major argument that Malcolm makes. Mr. Coleman concludes his argument by stating, "It’s now up to the United States to pay the tab it ran up. Calling this a debt is only the path to equality. It’s daunting. It isn’t a simple political slogan. It costs much more than banking black or buying black. The chore demands more than meager government lip service; the mission lacks the liberating autonomy and agency captured in so many songs and movies that imagine freedom through a black business." So, the same government that instituted slavery, Jim crow, segregation, the war on drugs and mass incarceration is now going to pay Black people back for all of that? You tell me who has the better plan? But I digress.

He points out in the article that skillful Conservative politicians - Nixon, Reagan and Trump - along with some Democratic politicians - mainly Obama - have co-opted the notion of Black capitalism to provide tax breaks to corporations and private equity firms (Does anyone really believe that the reason this happened is because a couple Black artists, musicians and Black business owner say that Black people should buy Black and support Black business? Use your common sense." This might be true, but it doesn't undercut the fundamental argument of that individuals who believe in Black capitalism push.

In my opinion, the fundamental premise of the argument is a silly one. Does the United States government need to pay it's debt to Black people? Of course! Should that stop Black people from trying to utilize capitalism to earn more money and build their community? Are the two in any way shape or form mutually exclusive? I get the feeling that Aaron Ross Coleman is a socialist, so when ever he hears about a Black person that supports utilizing capitalism to help solve our problems, he takes exception. Here's the problem though. Every where around the world people practice capitalism. Even in the communist countries like China or North Vietnam capitalism is practiced. Look at how China has descended like a cloud of locus all across Africa, the Caribbean and South America. If there comes a day when capitalism is no more, then fine. But until that day comes, Black people need to utilize all possible tools to get themselves out of the hole that they are in.

Will this solve our problems? No. But news flash. There is no solution to actually solve our problems. If there was it would be done already. And ultimately this is the biggest flaw in the article. It's easy to point out what won't work for Black people in our pursuit of equality. Aaron Ross Coleman doesn't like capitalism so he'll write an article about why Black capitalism isn't the way to go. Only to present a way that is just as dubious. Aaron is fond of quoting James Baldwin. Perhaps he should have quoted James Baldiwn's excerpt on the meeting between Dr. King and Elijah Muhammad instead.
 

lib123

Superstar
Joined
Jun 16, 2015
Messages
9,764
Reputation
913
Daps
20,387
I think some of these cats are paid to shyt on black entrepreneurship. They never shyt on black folks working for cac corporations tho :mjpls: they damn near say that’s better than starting your own shyt.

Seriously a lot of them do seem like divisive agents. White supremacy is built on acquiring and maintaining resources. That’s what people are saying when they say they’re “conservative.” Conservative = Conserving Resources.
 

⠀X ⠀

Geoff
Joined
Dec 19, 2017
Messages
20,677
Reputation
7,100
Daps
116,739
Didn't read, but black capitalism is most definitely the answer. To be a grown ass man begging for reparations, is some weak shyt. Yes they are owed, but do you really expect the government to give us all a bunch of cash? It's not likely

It's crazy how every other group understands that we live in a capitalistic society, but we have black liberals who shun it and then wonder why we don't get ahead.

Ok I did read the first few paragraphs, and this is definitely some c00n shyt.
 
Top