MikeBrownsJob
Seattle fan since 2013 *deal with it slime*
Fair enough. Just tired of the fanboys comparing a souped Trent Dilfer to the All-Time Winningnest Playoff Quarterback. It's disrespecful
Brady > Manning. The Discussion Ends
- Thread starter MikeBrownsJob
- Start date
Fair enough. Just tired of the fanboys comparing a souped Trent Dilfer to the All-Time Winningnest Playoff Quarterback. It's disrespecful
R.E.N. Spells Ren
Veteran
So, losing before the Super Bowl is more acceptable than making the Super Bowl and losing?
These guys will try everything to defend Manning.
You're putting Brady over Montana? Brady Stans are terrible.
Born2BKing
Veteran
Because Silver Spoon Brady is a system QB. It's like any QB in Chip Kelly's system at Oregon. You notice how mufukkas are always wide open out there.
mastermind
Rest In Power Kobe
name an all time great QB that isnt a system QB.
How was he along for the ride when he led multiple game-winning drives?
The first Patriots SB was a team effort, no denying that. But people are arguing just for the sake of arguing right now. And Brady was nowhere near as terrible as Peyton was. If anything you could point out that he got knocked out of the Steelers game.
Brady is better, but not for many of the terrible reasons in here, but the reasons to defend Peyton are equally horrible and you know they're getting dapped up by nothing but Peyton stans. None of us want to run through all the reasons all over again though.
But let me put it like this, Brady went to the SB last year with a mediocre defense and by throwing the ball to win, those are exactly the types of teams Peyton was losing with. So that's no excuse either. Ill-adivsed INT towards the end of that game aside, Brady won a game where his defense was letting Flacco style on them. Peyton was losing games as the 1 seed where HE played horrible. That's the problem, I'd be more sympathetic if he was playing well and losing, but he was wack too with his "unstoppable offenses" that got stopped in the playoffs. But that's all I'll say on this today.
Rapmastermind
Superstar
Peyton has won more Regular Season games than Brady and has broken more NFL Records than Brady has. Has more MVP's. Even this year, Manning won more regular season games than Brady did. The only reason Brady is even over Montana is cause he has played more seasons. Montana has better numbers and more Super Bowls with Less Playoff Appearances cause unlike Brady, Montana never lost a Bowl. Brady lost two so there's a debate if Brady is even the greatest Playoff QB.
R.E.N. Spells Ren
Veteran
Once Brady got comparable offensive weapons that Peyton had his whole career he seem set the league on fire.... Manning Stans like to ignore that
Born2BKing
Veteran
Peyton Manning didn't ever have a Bill Belichick.
Ignore him, he's a manning stan, he's been looking dumbfounded all year when he get shyt with facts. LOL@calling Brady silverspoon when Peyton's father was an NFL QB and he grew up with paper and is in every commercial while Brady turns them down.
MikeBrownsJob
Seattle fan since 2013 *deal with it slime*
even steve young was a system qb these nikkas clowns yo
All he does is dink and dunk down the field. It's so gimmicky
How was he along for the ride when he led multiple game-winning drives?
The first Patriots SB was a team effort, no denying that. But people are arguing just for the sake of arguing right now. And Brady was nowhere near as terrible as Peyton was. If anything you could point out that he got knocked out of the Steelers game.
Brady is better, but not for many of the terrible reasons in here, but the reasons to defend Peyton are equally horrible and you know they're getting dapped up by nothing but Peyton stans. None of us want to run through all the reasons all over again though.
But let me put it like this, Brady went to the SB last year with a mediocre defense and by throwing the ball to win, those are exactly the types of teams Peyton was losing with. So that's no excuse either. Ill-adivsed INT towards the end of that game aside, Brady won a game where his defense was letting Flacco style on them. Peyton was losing games as the 1 seed where HE played horrible. That's the problem, I'd be more sympathetic if he was playing well and losing, but he was wack too with his "unstoppable offenses" that got stopped in the playoffs. But that's all I'll say on this today.
Close the thread