Brady > Manning. The Discussion Ends

[PortCityProphet]

And he won those 3 rings all by himself right? Dude threw 1 frigging touchdown pass the entire postseason the year he won his 1st ring.

C'mon man stop hittin these dudes with sense and facts. It's not right.

 

[AkaDemiK]

Neither one of them has anything without their D. The one year Indy's D steps up they win and ever since NE d has been pretty gashed they haven't won shyt.
You can use this type of stuff when comparing basketball players but not football cause its too many people needed to win a ship in football. So stop using superbowls when comparing 2 football players it's one of the dumbest arguments I see.

 

[GzUp]

I've never seen Brady choke in any type of game

 

[JLova]

3 rings breh, 3 rings.

I like how some people think Manning was the sole reason for the colts ring but Brady was along for the ride.

1 TD pass in the entire preseason for that 1st ring.

Peyton was terrible that SB run, but you don't have anyone here propping him up and giving him legendary stats just off that SB ring like Brady stans do.

Don't talk shyt about Manning's SB run, then completely excuse Brady for being along for the ride in the 1st one.

 

[Savior]

If you know football from watching over the years and not listening to talking heads its been very obvious for a while.



Sent from Seattle, by way of Ann Arbor on Tapatalk: The Remix

True...its been evident for a while. Last couple of years is just burying the nail in the coffin. Manning stans will always deny it tho even if Brady wins 3 more SB's

 

[Loose]

No arguments here... manning even has had some of the best defenses and still choke. Even last years playoff loss brady damn sure didn't choke his defense did.

 

[JLova]

Defense wins championships. If your D doesn't step up...goodbye. You also have to be balanced on offense.

 

[DStyles]

He also has more SB losses than Peyton. I can play this game too.

Against the better Manning :duh:


But yeah, Brady>>>>peychoke

Elite Manning>>>peychoke

Only so long fake thugs can pretend

 

[Born2BKing]

No arguments here... manning even has had some of the best defenses and still choke. Even last years playoff loss brady damn sure didn't choke his defense did.

Including the defense that got fukking torched up and down the field yesterday?

 

[Formerly known as...]

1 TD pass in the entire preseason for that 1st ring.

Peyton was terrible that SB run, but you don't have anyone here propping him up and giving him legendary stats just off that SB ring like Brady stans do.

Don't talk shyt about Manning's SB run, then completely excuse Brady for being along for the ride in the 1st one.

If you read some of my past posts, i clown manning at times but I do acknowledge his greatness. I just don't like when people act like he is head and shoulders better than Brady etc...I wouldn't ride with Manning in January

 

[Loose]

Including the defense that got fukking torched up and down the field yesterday?

he rubbed off on them , they had the game won anyway until manning wanted to be jr. Manning= Greatest regular season stat padder of all time

 

[MikeBrownsJob]

I always thought this was common knowledge for the past 5 years.

I did as well, but I am deeply disturbed by the fanboys. It's Last night's loss is being blamed on everyone not named Manning when he choked in overtime.

His own coach doesn't trust the ball in his hands when the game is on the line which is why they took a knee with 30 seconds left and 2 timeouts. Meanwhile in Atlanta Matt Ryan is giving the keys to the Cadillac to win the game.

Manning is done. Regular season warrior. Playoff chump

 

[JLova]

No arguments here... manning even has had some of the best defenses and still choke. Even last years playoff loss brady damn sure didn't choke his defense did.

The funny thing is the definition of "choke" changes based on who loses games. Brady has had worse games than Manning today...but those don't count for some strange reason.

All that needs to say is Manning has not had the luxury of having bad to decent games except the one season he won it all. Brady's had 3 pick games and still advanced. That should tell you all you need to know.

 

[Born2BKing]

he rubbed off on them , they had the game won anyway until manning wanted to be jr. Manning= Greatest regular season stat padder of all time

They had the game won until that safety decided to let someone blow by him in an obvious prevent situation.

 

[BLAZO da GAWD]

1 TD pass in the entire preseason for that 1st ring.

Peyton was terrible that SB run, but you don't have anyone here propping him up and giving him legendary stats just off that SB ring like Brady stans do.

Don't talk shyt about Manning's SB run, then completely excuse Brady for being along for the ride in the 1st one.

because they cant. which brings me back to my earlier post. manning stans can cling onto nothing when stating why manning is the best besides flailing pre-snap arms and popularity contests aka mvp awards

what other argument do manning stans have?!?

the difference with brady's first SB is that was his first year as a starter in the nfl. manning is still choking and making favre-like plays in his 17th year. i know no one is perfect but u cant call a player the GOAT and he has a below .500 record in the offs. im very aware its a team game but thats a spit in the face to players that match manning in reg season achievements and surpass him in playoff achievements