Brady > Manning. The Discussion Ends

[BLAZO da GAWD]

just like his qb

 

[Carlos Huerta]

i've yet to hear one legitimate argument from a Seyton stan on why he's better than Brady historically...

all i keep reading are attempts to discredit Brady saying he isn't better for x,y,z reason, that then gets refuted by a knowledgeable poster a couple posts later

"Seyton" though? really man?

 

[BLAZO da GAWD]

"Seyton" though? really man?

Prollums?

 

[Robbie3000]

Oh now lets consider all the other factors. :belli:

Playoff records count. Super Bowl wins Count. This is the QB position. You get unfair criticism and you get unfair praise. When you have two QBs as comparable in stats as these two, then you have to factor in how they perform when it counts.

It's not like we are comparing Terry Bradshaw to Manning here. We are talking about two elite QBs with comparable QB stats.

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

name an all time great QB that isnt a system QB.

Staubach, Favre(yeah I said it), Marino....

But you do have a point with most HOF QBs being somewhat system QBs

 

[mastermind]

Staubach, Favre(yeah I said it), Marino....

But you do have a point with most HOF QBs being somewhat system QBs

Staubach who spent his entire career in Landry's offense?

Favre who looked like crap for the Jets when they werent running a WCO?


The only one I will give you is Marino.

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

Staubach who spent his entire career in Landry's offense?

Favre who looked like crap for the Jets when they werent running a WCO?


The only one I will give you is Marino.

Disagree with you on that one.. I wouldn't call Landry's offense a system in the contemporary sense...But I respect your opinion...

 

[Swiggy]

Eli coming fro the crown, but now Brady sits at the throne

 

[MikeBrownsJob]

Oh now lets consider all the other factors. :belli:

Playoff records count. Super Bowl wins Count. This is the QB position. You get unfair criticism and you get unfair praise. When you have two QBs as comparable in stats as these two, then you have to factor in how they perform when it counts.

It's not like we are comparing Terry Bradshaw to Manning here. We are talking about two elite QBs with comparable QB stats.

I know these dudes keep on with the false equivalencies like "Robert horry > Jordan" if you factor in rings.

No one is saying Robert Horry is the GOAT of anything so that is not a valid argument. When you have two with comparable stats you go on down the line and that includes Super Bowl wins and Playoff wins.

Brady > Manning.

 

[SubLyminalz]

No arguments here... manning even has had some of the best defenses and still choke. Even last years playoff loss brady damn sure didn't choke his defense did.

what year did manning have a great defense?


the year he won a super bowl he statistically has the worse defense in the entire league, they wasnt even supposed to beat kc first round.

 

[Big Boss]

no superbowl wins since spygate

 

[AkaDemiK]

no superbowl wins since spygate

 

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

no superbowl wins since spygate

No but he'd still be better than Peyton

 

[Ineedmoney504]

no superbowl wins since spygate

and he didnt look trash against the ravens

 

[Swiggy]

Both fell to Bishop Ray Lewis. The discussion is still over