Birnin Zana
Honorary Wakandan
He will never have a problem with fundraising due to his popularity and the loyalty of black celebrities aligned with the program. Once he's out of office it's obvious he will be more involved in the decision making. There's nothing to discredit here and people have already benefited from the program.
What policy did you want? To stop the police from killing black folks? That's never going to happen. He doesn't have mind control over white people. What policy? Affirmative action is already in place but it won't stop white people from not hiring black people. Even though the unemployment rate for black people is currently 8.1%. It was 12.7% when he took office and continued to rise as the effects of the recession continued to hit.
My overall stance on MBK is best summarized by this segment of the following article.
Obama’s Battle for Black Boys: My Brother’s Keeper, 2 Years Later
The biggest criticism of President Obama and his initiative is that it’s not a federal program that addresses the systemic issues across a range of policies that cause young men of color to face such daunting odds. As Columbia University professor Fredrick Harris wrote in a recent report for the Brookings Institution (pdf), “[E]xisting laws and practices that perpetuate the conditions that poor and working-class minority youth face will end up counteracting the good works that the My Brother’s Keeper initiative is trying to accomplish.”
As a result, there is only so much of an impact that this initiative can have. Not only are the root causes of the issue left unaddressed, but MBK has been in place for just two years, and that’s much too short a time frame to make a dent in a problem that was literally centuries in the making.
The president also appears to champion the respectability politics for which he occasionally takes heat. A significant part of the My Brother’s Keeper message to boys of color is to study hard, pull up their pants, and be twice as good because they cannot expect anyone to have any sympathy for them and their circumstances. On this score, he is not necessarily wrong, but the assessment is clearly incomplete. Again, without significant policy-reform proposals to accompany such guidance, this initiative seems to address only the margins of a much deeper problem.





