That’s kind of the point they are judging the gift of a couple without (from what I can tell) any context on the situation. It may not work for them but it wasn’t for them and there doesn’t seem to be any ill intent from him so it kind of make the criticism worthless. They should make sure their partner understands what type of gifts they want because apparently she has.Yeah but I couldn't be with a women like that and I understand the criticism. I guess since Im not from the sticks but a major city.