brehs lets talk cologne game

Trav

TTWF🅾️.
Supporter
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
40,234
Reputation
15,107
Daps
110,783
Reppin
Zone 6 BIA Silver Bullets BlockO


The above is my SOTD. My 1st impression was to stop and ask myself, "did I grab a decent from Tiziana by mistake?" :lolbron:

But the difference is, where Tiziana would turn it up as far as the projection and theatrics of it all--Creed is more polished & restrained.

I kind of wanted them to push the cinnamon a little further in the open. But after about 20 mins, the vanilla, almond, and bourbon really stuck out to grab my attention.

Overall though, it's too 'soft' for me. Too safe. I have other joints that do this a little bit better, especially at the price point.
 

Why-Fi

gnap
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
19,882
Reputation
3,017
Daps
28,054
Reppin
smurf village
just copped l'homme ideal cologne forte. my 3rd l'homme ideal and 8th guerlain bottle. I can't fkin wait until it gets here

sotd bdc lexclusif. usually it's endymion concentre on these days but the chanel performs better
 

Trav

TTWF🅾️.
Supporter
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
40,234
Reputation
15,107
Daps
110,783
Reppin
Zone 6 BIA Silver Bullets BlockO
Grabbed Bond No.9 New York Nights a few weeks bacc......but in candle form :ohlawd:

I know there's no bananas listed in the notes, but I'll be damned if it doesn't give off a banana pudding essence. The more I burn it, the coffee starts to seep out of it as well. I know it probably won't be the same if and when I get a decant of it, but I'm with all the gourmand and decadent fukkery. Plus, I can think of a few things to layer it with.
 

WIA20XX

Superstar
Joined
May 24, 2022
Messages
10,356
Reputation
4,840
Daps
31,783
SOTD - Amouage - Royal Tobacco

Scent - 11 out of 10
Longevity - 11 out of 10
Projection - 11 out off 10 - straight room filler

but

Wearability - 2 out of 10 - Snow on the ground, Night at the Kennedy Center, just got a divorce and DGAF... - it's just not a lot of scenarios I would rock this.

I swear if I didn't WFH, I'd get rid of 99% of the collection.
 

Kidd Dibiase

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Nov 23, 2013
Messages
78,211
Reputation
11,037
Daps
213,993
photo-2026-02-05-12-28-45.jpg


idk why i got Vanguard, because if have Afnan Supremacy CE...but yeah smells the same [which is a good thing]

the clear winners by far in this is Forever Wanted Absolu [to me way better than Elixir] and YSL Y Iced

This gonna be the last thing i try from City Rhythm [this doesn't even smell bad but im whelmed]

YSL Y Elixir smells nice too but Iced is blowing this out the water

[skin testing Tempo on one hand and YSL Y Elixir on the other...will update]
 
Last edited:

WIA20XX

Superstar
Joined
May 24, 2022
Messages
10,356
Reputation
4,840
Daps
31,783
SOTD - Xerjoff - Empiryan

Notes
  • Cypriol From India , Tobacco Leaves
  • Cedar From Atlas , Incense From Oman, Patchouli From Singapore
  • Vanilla From Madagascar, Oriental , Labdanum
Great bottle (like Valentino)

The scent is good, but not nearly as epic as it should be.

3-5 mls, nothing more.

Incidentally picked up Scent of Woods - Plum in Cognac Vintage '24.

If you like the OG, this flanker is the same - just a bit more woods at the opening, but a richer plum/cognac wood throughout.
 

BK The Great

Veteran
Joined
Nov 21, 2015
Messages
64,242
Reputation
8,460
Daps
158,640
Reppin
BK NY
Been getting some samples off social media ads like Creed Aventus, YSL MYSLF, Givenchy Gentleman Society & Amouage Reflection Man. Also picked up a cheap bottle of Polo 1 Pony Colection. I prefer aquatic and citrus notes over most the other stuff but can wear other ones too.
 

Primetime21

This my city
Supporter
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
45,120
Reputation
7,649
Daps
172,879
Reppin
Lemongrass, cherries, alkaline water
SOTD - Amouage - Royal Tobacco

Scent - 11 out of 10
Longevity - 11 out of 10
Projection - 11 out off 10 - straight room filler

but

Wearability - 2 out of 10 - Snow on the ground, Night at the Kennedy Center, just got a divorce and DGAF... - it's just not a lot of scenarios I would rock this.

I swear if I didn't WFH, I'd get rid of 99% of the collection.
You got the full bottle or a decant? I have a 2ml and enjoy it, but as you alluded to can't imagine the scenarios where I'm wearing it to justify a bottle. This sample is going to last me a couple of years :mjlol:
 

WIA20XX

Superstar
Joined
May 24, 2022
Messages
10,356
Reputation
4,840
Daps
31,783
You got the full bottle or a decant? I have a 2ml and enjoy it, but as you alluded to can't imagine the scenarios where I'm wearing it to justify a bottle. This sample is going to last me a couple of years :mjlol:

Yeah, I caught it on sale for like 160/180 (full packaging).

Need to figure out if I can get transferred to London or Oslo or something to rock this on the regular :pachaha:
 

Kidd Dibiase

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Nov 23, 2013
Messages
78,211
Reputation
11,037
Daps
213,993
update

Forever Wanted Absolu, I'm not a fan of the full dry down. Opening and the mid is fire though

YSL Y Elixir, i like this all the way through. Still think Iced is better though

free samples were Jo Milano Roll it 18 which was dope [not sure if this is an original or clone] and Roll it 2 and i did not like this at all
 
Top