brehs lets talk cologne game

WIA20XX

Superstar
Joined
May 24, 2022
Messages
7,791
Reputation
3,714
Daps
24,362
Been curious about this brand's Tobacco line. They have a Cuban Tobacco and Peruvian Tobacco that I hear are pretty good but its getting way to warm for these right now. Might Scentsplit it later.

SOTD-YSL-Myslf EDP

I like Cuban, haven't tried a Peruvian. The Jamaican flanker has the wrong notes on fragrantica.
 

WIA20XX

Superstar
Joined
May 24, 2022
Messages
7,791
Reputation
3,714
Daps
24,362
What's your take on this?

At one point I owned Triumph of Bacchus, and sampled PDM Carlisle. In hindsight I think enjoyed the latter more but having owned TOB already I thought it was redundant to have both. These two are said to be in the same universe as Red Tobacco hence why I never bothered checking that out but I did have Jamaican Tobacco on my watchlist.

I'm not buying full bottles, so redundancy is not really a concern. The idea that JT smells like Red Tobacco worries me.


40 bucks for 5mls? Yikes.

17 for 2 is better, but I dislike Red Tobacco a lot. But I dunno.

That said I started getting "high dollar" decants because I already grabbed a good chunk of every popular fragrance out there, which tend to be cheap. And that lead to popular niche, and then further down the distribution curve... And even then I barely scratch the surface of what is out there
 

WIA20XX

Superstar
Joined
May 24, 2022
Messages
7,791
Reputation
3,714
Daps
24,362
SOTD - Zoologist - T-Rex

Bottle-JD-60ml-Front-Tyrannosaurus-Rex_800x.jpg



Top Notes: Bergamot, Black Pepper, Fir, Laurel Leaf, Neroli, Nutmeg
Heart Notes: Champaca, Geranium, Jasmine, Osmanthus, Rose, Ylang Ylang
Base Notes: Resins, Cade, Cedar, Civet*, Frankincense, Leather*, Patchouli, Sandalwood, Vanilla

All the floral stuff and sweet stuff? You gotta be a bloodhound to catch them.

Black Pepper and Nutmeg are here, but htis is dominated by Resins, Cade, and arguably leather.

Like 1805 Tonnere - this is definitely something I wear for myself. Panty Dropper, more like Panty PIcker Upper and Call UBER ASAP.
 

Monoblock

Smoooth
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
30,839
Reputation
10,280
Daps
119,933
Reppin
Houston
I like Cuban, haven't tried a Peruvian. The Jamaican flanker has the wrong notes on fragrantica.
Just saw that review and if that Jamaican Tobacco is anything like Red Tobacco I'm not interested. Argos- Triumph of Bacchus is the perfected version of that DNA IMO
 

Stuntone

Louisiana Made, DC PAID!
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
18,882
Reputation
5,791
Daps
90,861
Reppin
IT Cert-Gang Mafia, GMB and HOH
There's just too many great fragrances + their flankers!! Intense, Extreme, Elixir, etc.


Kevin Samuel made me step my game up, ive probably bought 30 bottles these past 3 years. That's more than enough, im doing to start buying less.
 

JQ Legend

Veteran
Joined
Dec 9, 2013
Messages
25,457
Reputation
12,798
Daps
75,995
Been curious about this brand's Tobacco line. They have a Cuban Tobacco and Peruvian Tobacco that I hear are pretty good but its getting way to warm for these right now. Might Scentsplit it later.

SOTD-YSL-Myslf EDP
You prefer scent split over decantx? :jbhmm:
 

Monoblock

Smoooth
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
30,839
Reputation
10,280
Daps
119,933
Reppin
Houston
You prefer scent split over decantx?

:jbhmm:
For me yes. I prefer Scent Split b/c they send stuff out lightning fast (2-3 days max) and their selection is in a league of its own. Decant X is cool but their selection is limited also I hate their style of decants along with Micro Perfumes. I hate Maxaroma decants with a passion. Mines always came with no labels on the decants and a few of them leaked out completely.
 
Last edited:

WIA20XX

Superstar
Joined
May 24, 2022
Messages
7,791
Reputation
3,714
Daps
24,362
SOTD - BYREDO - Tobacco Mandarin

good_one_mob-tobaccomandarin_1_.jpg


This retails $350 for 50mls

They're insane.

Like all Byredo scents, you pay a lot for very little performance.

And that would be all Kool and the Gang, if the scent itself was out of this world.

Instead, its a light sweet citrus on the top, the aforementioned mandarin, with a tobacco-ish base? motif?
As far as tobacco scents go, it's fine. Not great like Tobacconist/Smoky Tobacco/Tobacco Vanille, but not horrid like Red Tobacco.

This was one of those high dollar decants that I put off for YEARS, before I finally ran out of things to buy curiosity finally took hold.

I only got 2 mls of this, and I think evaporation really did a number on it. 2mls should be about 21 days of wear, but at best I've worn this one other time. It's got maybe one more day in it...
 

3rdWorld

Veteran
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
47,184
Reputation
4,560
Daps
138,390
For me yes. I prefer Scent Split b/c they send stuff out lightning fast (2-3 days max) and their selection is in a league of its own. Decant X is cool but their selection is limited also I hate their style of decants along with Micro Perfumes. I hate Maxaroma decants with a passion. Mines always came with no labels on the decants and a few of them leaked out completely.

I've used Scentsplit, DecantX, TwistedLily and a couple others.

Decantx has too many fire bottles sold out, with no idea when they'll restock and they ship after a couple weeks.

TwistedLilly is great, much better.
Their decants are in nice, proper professional bottles within a nice card and proper labeling. Some are actually from the producers.
I paid $5.00 for 2ML decants, some were $9.00 but they had a great selection.
 

JQ Legend

Veteran
Joined
Dec 9, 2013
Messages
25,457
Reputation
12,798
Daps
75,995
For me yes. I prefer Scent Split b/c they send stuff out lightning fast (2-3 days max) and their selection is in a league of its own. Decant X is cool but their selection is limited also I hate their style of decants along with Micro Perfumes. I hate Maxaroma decants with a passion. Mines always came with no labels on the decants and a few of them leaked out completely.
The stuff that’s on both are usually cheaper at Decantx, at least the few I looked up. :ehh:

Also that black owned brand that sell Sin Santo and Sage, Whiskey Rose etc has a sale this week for 25% off :mjgrin:

I might finally cop :mjgrin:
 
Top