Brehs... Lets try and quantify players based on achievements

[Panther]

I was thinking about this earlier... What if we compared players based on achievements and gave them an overall number that we could compare.

For example:

2 pts for an MVP, 3 pts for a championship/super bowl, 2 pts for Finals MVP/SB MVP, 1 pt for All star selection etc.

Would be interesting to see where certain players ranked. What do yall think?

Post a pt scale if you think this could work

 

[PortCityProphet]

Idk I feel some type of way bout media awarded accomplishments. And how do you weigh a persons role on a ship squad

 

[Panther]

We could call it something like the Coli Career Index

Idk I feel some type of way bout media awarded accomplishments. And how do you weigh a persons role on a ship squad

the thought is to compare superstars, or people at the same position imo

You know the stans are just gonna use it against each other anyway

 

[PortCityProphet]

We could call it something like the Coli Career Index

the thought is to compare superstars, or people at the same position imo

You know the stans are just gonna use it against each other anyway

There's no point in coming up with anything reasonable for stans. All logic and facts go out the window concerning them anyway.

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

Are we including college achivements? Because (sneak preview)



Charles Woodson is GOAT by what i expect a scoring system to be...

 

[Panther]

Are we including college achivements? Because (sneak preview)



Charles Woodson is GOAT by what i expect a scoring system to be...

my thought is to split em between college and pros... dont want scoring to be skewed by a college standout who didnt do much in the pros
like that fukkboy tebow... but in the college section he would be near the top

 

[Jesus Shuttlesworth]

It's all subjective, therefore your entire point system would be subjective, thus accomplishing nothing.

Just saying