Brehs, where does Andre Johnson rank all-time in WR history?

[BrehWyatt]

Brehs, we not gonna shyt on David Carr...... Be amazed that Dre caught all them passes from him, with damn near no offensive line to protect Carr.

David would have been a solid QB if he just had an average line. Cat was led to the slaughter every week.

Nah, he's not a holier than thou fakkit like Graduel Carter....and he hasn't rubbed people the wrong way like Moss and TO.

Also this. As good a player as Andre is, by most, if not all accounts, he's an even better person.

 

[Chill b]

Top 15

 

[Chill b]

Top 15

 

[Flash Thunderton]

He's in that first tier of guys under Moss/Owens of the modern era. That guy that played for the Colts was good but also reaped the benefits of playing with Peyton his whole career. I'm going to say he's top 10-15 all time.

If Andre is right under Moss/Owens



Would you say Calvin is right up there with them?

 

[Primetime21]

If Andre is right under Moss/Owens



Would you say Calvin is right up there with them?

What I said was he was in the tier under Moss/Owens of the modern era as in wide receivers who came up after Moss/Owens, I didnt say he was right under them all time. Dre, Fitzgerald, Reggie, Calvin are all in that tier of best WR's in the post Moss/Owens era in different order.

 

[SoulController]

you cant factor in TD's when he played with trash his whole career. Schaub had 1 decent year and 1 very good year, thats it everything else was awful

it would keep him out of GOAT discussions, but hes easily a top 10-12 as is and will finish in the top 5-8

 

[stepbackj34spud]

How this dude only has 65 touchdowns tho?
That's pathetic lmao. I can't take Dre serious when Moss and Owens almost have 2.5x as many career touchdowns as Johnson.

 

[MegaTronBomb!]

How this dude only has 65 touchdowns tho?
That's pathetic lmao. I can't take Dre serious when Moss and Owens almost have 2.5x as many career touchdowns as Johnson.

Moss and Owens also had the benefit of playing with the following factors
- that 98 Vikings squad and the 07 Pats
- fakkit ass Graduel Carter playing on the other side of Moss
- Steve Young,Jeff Garcia, Donovan McNabb, Tony Romo,Tom Brady at QB

Carr never threw more than 16 TD's in any season with the Texans, and Schaub only became a good QB when he got to throw the ball 550x a season...and even then, only threw for 29 TD's

 

[duncanthetall]

Don't care Who the QB Was. Nobody told him to keep resigning with that squad. Still knocking him for the TDs. Top 15 tho

 

[MegaTronBomb!]

Don't care Who the QB Was. Nobody told him to keep resigning with that squad. Still knocking him for the TDs. Top 15 tho

What do you mean "keep resigning" with them? He only had one extension that got signed in 07

 

[stepbackj34spud]

Moss and Owens also had the benefit of playing with the following factors
- that 98 Vikings squad and the 07 Pats
- fakkit ass Graduel Carter playing on the other side of Moss
- Steve Young,Jeff Garcia, Donovan McNabb, Tony Romo,Tom Brady at QB

Carr never threw more than 16 TD's in any season with the Texans, and Schaub only became a good QB when he got to throw the ball 550x a season...and even then, only threw for 29 TD's

Only 65 tho? nikka lol

 

[Scottie Drippin]

Only 65 tho? nikka lol

What part of that do you not understand? One year the Texans threw 13tds as a team, and 5 were to him.

He's caught damn near 50% of the tds the Texans have thrown as a franchise.

 

[MegaTronBomb!]

Only 65 tho? nikka lol

Breh.... that Offensive line for the Texans in those early years was fukking horrible.

David Carr got sacked 76,15,49,68, and 41 times as their starting QB.

How you gonna throw any TD's to anybody with a line that gives up historic sack numbers?

 

[Roid Jones]

Top 15

 

[Millions]

Top 10 is right but Steve Smith better be on y'all top 10 list both them played with bums most of there career and still put in work...