Brehs,why isnt Kurt Warner mentioned when talking top QB's?

[Bboystyle]

Dude got a SB ring and took a crappy 9-7 AZ team to the SB and made them relevant and almost got them their first SB win ever with the 19th ranked defense.

He's on all time lists and a HoF candidate.


has a 9-3 playoff record

Has a consistently good year almost every season



i guess his only down fall was injuries.

 

[bl2k8]

If he could have either the 01 bowl or the 09 won his status would be a lot different

3 bowl trips and two rings is Big Ben status

 

[Mantis Toboggan M.D.]

Dude got a SB ring and took a crappy 9-7 AZ team to the SB and made them relevant and almost got them their first SB win ever with the 19th ranked defense.

He's on all time lists and a HoF candidate.


has a 9-3 playoff record

Has a consistently good year almost every season



i guess his only down fall was injuries.

That 2002-06 stretch. Shame because he was always my favorite player. We will see him in canton though. That'll be quite the recognition. Only great hall of fame level qb to go unbeaten at home in the playoffs too. Manning, Brady, Rodgers, roger, aikman, young, favre, Montana, elway, marino, brees, all of them lost at home in the playoffs. Warner never did. Never lost a conference title game and has the top 3 yardage outputs in super bowl history too. We remember how great he was.

 

[Mantis Toboggan M.D.]

If he could have either the 01 bowl or the 09 won his status would be a lot different

3 bowl trips and two rings is Big Ben status

And the two he lost were horribly officiated. Should have won those games.

 

[Urbane]

Probably due to the strange development of his career. Warner went from grocery bag boy to super bowl hero to mentoring eli manning to once again putting up elite numbers.

 

[Bboystyle]

If he could have either the 01 bowl or the 09 won his status would be a lot different

3 bowl trips and two rings is Big Ben status

i can see the 01 bowl game being used against his for two INT's but the 09 bowl game was not his fault.

 

[MikelArteta]

That thumb injury messed him

Still a hofer in my eyes

 

[DPG4Life]

the patriots cheating cost him a 2nd superbowl

 

[mozichrome]

wasnt they talking about this season could kurt come outta retirement for the cards

 

[BlackAchilles]

He was good but had kind of a short/inconsistent run

 

[Lakers Offseason]

He lost because of who he married

 

[resurrection]

I think he's a HoF'er.. I think the only reason he isn't more consistently mentioned among top QBs is because his run was shorter than others, he had no hype coming into the league, was a bit older so he wasn't in the public eye through college so we didn't have that "he grew up before our eyes" factor.

 

[Broad Street Bully]

Cuz nikkas didn't forget that nasty ass Giants run he had

Got benched in favor of Marc Bulger and Eli lmao

 

[Black White Sox Hat]

Has a consistently good year almost every season

I don't know about this.Didn't Marc Bulger take his job?

 

[AJtheOne]

so we gonna act like during his best seasons, he didn't play in a dome and didn't always have 2 top wrs