Hitman or Rocky.
As a pure mark of a kid it was Warrior all day long, but as an adult I can't co-sign the bullshyt he was on elsewhere.
Yeah, Hitman loved the smell of his own shyt and he did have a large part in his own downfall, but the Summerslam '92 main event is one of the peaks of wrestling for me. Bret's only weakness in the ring was once everyone started noticing the moves of death (something that wrestlers copy FAR too often these days)
Rocky is just undeniable. GOAT mic/promo skills. Good technically and able to pull heat from an igloo whether he's heel or face. It's no coincidence that the rest of the entertainment industry loves him as much as wrestling fans.