Can any Jay Z fans come in here and explain to me why he’s the goat?

[semicko82]

I don't get it either. Who's bumping Dirt Off Your Shoulder in 2023?

You can say that about any mainstream song that came out in 03

 

[JustCKing]

You can say that about any mainstream song that came out in 03

You could say that about any song period as listening preferences differ from person to person. Someone who doesn't particularly care for Thriller could say who's listening to Thriller in 2023.

It's really a pointless question to be asking in 2023 as people literally listen to any song they want to listen to. You could pull up YouTube views or go to Spotify to look up his most played songs. Same with Apple Music.

 

[semicko82]

You could say that about any song period as listening preferences differ from person to person. Someone who doesn't particularly care for Thriller could say who's listening to Thriller in 2023.

It's really a pointless question to be asking in 2023 as people literally listen to any song they want to listen to. You could pull up YouTube views or go to Spotify to look up his most played songs. Same with Apple Music.

Exactly
That's why I didn't get the point the poster I quoted was trying to make

 

[mikishere]

we can but i dont think jay-z fans look at jay-z like a deity who they have to rush to their rescue and defend every hour of the day

shouldve put nas in the title if you wanted a plat thread

 

[semicko82]

we can but i dont think jay-z fans look at jay-z like a deity who they have to rush to their rescue and defend every hour of the day

shouldve put nas in the title if you wanted a plat thread

Yup
At the end of day Hov fans know he's far from from a perfect artist and knows he has trash in his discography.
A true fan can acknowledge the good and bad

 

[bigde09]

Exactly
That's why I didn't get the point the poster I quoted was trying to make

His music didn't age well.

 

[Consigliere]

I always suspected that Nas stans were just thirsty for some human contact.

Thread confirms it.




Maybe if your favorite rapper made music that moved the crowd you guys wouldn’t be so lonely?

 

[semicko82]

His music didn't age well.

All of his music?

 

[Piff Perkins]

His music didn't age well.

How can you possibly make this argument when 30 million people are listening to his music on Spotify, monthly? I'd love for you to name some rappers whose music has aged better and I guarantee no one you pick is being listened to more than Jay.

 

[Why-Fi]

because he said so

 

[semicko82]

 

[SuburbanPimp]

I mean he is

Would love to hear the case for someone else though

 

[African Peasant]

His catalog is too weak to be the GOAT.

Also, he never had a style.

Very talented guy however and top 10 easily .

 

[Zero]

I swear some of you are the most boring people in the world. Writing the same few sentences over and over to the same people without an original thought for decades on end.

DECADES

 

[Zero]

I always suspected that Nas stans were just thirsty for some human contact.

Thread confirms it.




Maybe if your favorite rapper made music that moved the crowd you guys wouldn’t be so lonely?

Kings Disease 12 on the way