Can Jalen Hurts be better than Donovan Mcnabb was

[broller]

Before Moss and Gronk who did Brady have?

One nicca at WR won Super Bowl MVP and was never heard from before or after that game

I don't think people are comparing McNabb to Brady here. It's like saying "why can't so and so do this? Michael Jordan did.."


Not true about Branch. Branch was traded to Seattle for a first round pick in 2006. He didn't do much in Seattle though.

 

[broller]

1. WHO THE fukk SAID
MCNABB WAS BETTER THAN BRADY?

2. BRADY THREW FOR 145 YARDS
IN THAT FIRST SUPER BOWL
AGAINST THE GOAT OFFENSE
AND WON
WHICH MEANS HIS DEFENSE
DESERVES ALL THE CREDIT FOR THAT ONE



​

Facts. I mean , the Patriots scored 13 pts on offense and won. If you told anyone the Rams D would hold NE's O to 13 before the game, no one would have picked NE to win.

 

[Silkk]

I don't think people are comparing McNabb to Brady here. It's like saying "why can't so and so do this? Michael Jordan did.."


Not true about Branch. Branch was traded to Seattle for a first round pick in 2006. He didn't do much in Seattle though.

Im not comparing them either more so their weapons

Peyton is my GOAT, had more weapons than both and couldn’t get it done until he did but should have way more

 

[Street Knowledge]

Mcnabb had a much better coach

 

[wire28]

Yes

FCK NO

 

[Ohene]

McNabb was better. Hurts has a lot more around him on both sides of the ball. Also, comparing stats between such different eras isn't valid.

Go back and watch Mcnabb playoff highlights

 

[Ohene]

The eagles put shyt aroubd mcnabb until he had T.O. westbrook was a solid back in his time but no where bear barkley.

The eagles have done a hell of a job surrounding jalen with talent upon talebt. Mcnabb went to 5 NFC title ganes with a choking Andy reid and average supporting cast sans T.O, westbrook and djax

Mcnabb was a bigger choker then Reid
Go back and watch the games in retrospect and you’ll see

 

[Art Barr]

Mcnabb is better

But we in a different era now

Hell nah.

Mcnabb is nuffin but the scary parochial coddled guy at Mr Carmel.

Hurts is way better than mcnabb.
Mcnabb would throw up like Willie beeman. All because he was hating on to. In the superbowl. Plus setback black qb's to the stone ages. fukk mcnabb.

It rhyme with mc__ag

Art Barr

 

[Harry B]

old head nba fans coming into NFL with this bullshyt

In the NFL we can compare the new and old generation without your trash hating ass nba takes.


One thing is true, that tush push thing is such a lethal quality move that people wanna ban it. People tend to disregard it when they talk about hurts

 

[Ohene]

old head nba fans coming into NFL with this bullshyt

In the NFL we can compare the new and old generation without your trash hating ass nba takes.


One thing is true, that tush push thing is such a lethal quality move that people wanna ban it. People tend to disregard it when they talk about hurts

breh...week after week I would watch teams fukk up fourth and 1s at the 1 yard line or pivotal 4th and 1/inches plays. People shyt on Hurts for "stealing" touchdowns but that shyt is integral to the success of the team. He doesnt get nearly enough credit for it.

Even when he gets injured we dont run it and it affects us

 

[NYC Rebel]

If Hurts ran with intention like he did during the super bowl, he exceeds Donavan easily

 

[BuckFilly]

Hell no

 

[Dr. Narcisse]

I get people calling McNabb a choker. However, that Tampa defense was one of the best ever. That was McNabb with no #1 wr.

Super Bowl was a disappointment but that was maybe the best Brady team imo (that won the Super Bowl)

 

[Reality Check]

This is a tad misleading.

McNabb had nowhere near the talent at Receiver his first five seasons in the league that Hurts currently. He did not have one single 1,000 receiver until the Eagles finally traded for TO in 2004; the best season a receiver had during that span was James Thrash who had 63/833/8 in 2001. He also missed the final 6 regular season games in the 2002 season due to a broken foot (happened to have thrown for 4 touchdowns during that game while playing with the broken foot because Arizona was that bad). McNabb had to overcome a lot of bullshyt play at WR; it wasn't until later in his time with the Eagles that they were able to get talent at WR (DeJack & Maclin), but Vick and Foles benefitted more from them than McNabb did.

With that said, the one thing McNabb lacked that Hurts has is the killer instinct. McNabb was a goof at times he should have been serious. There's no scenario where you'd see Hurts dancing for the camera before a game like McNabb did during the one playoff game in Dallas (think it was his last game for the Eagles ironically enough).

 

[No1]

Why do people keep comparing stats of guys who played in different eras?