Lucky_Lefty
Dreams Are Colder Than Death...
Brad Johnson won a title. Who was Bama's last? Joe "panty hose wearing batty boy" Namath?
Cardale Jones or Jameis Winston
- Thread starter Topps
- Start date
Tony D'Amato
It's all about the inches
Its almost a strike against u if u win a natl chip or the Heisman.
King Crimson
Member of a very exclusive gang
Brad Johnson won a title. Who was Bama's last? Joe "panty hose wearing batty boy" Namath?
Hold your tongue when you talk about the GOAT Jet, Joe Willie.
Caredale has played 4 better teams than Jameis career
Caredale actually beat the team that embarrassed Jameis
We're any of our QBs drafted number 1Brad Johnson won a title. Who was Bama's last? Joe "panty hose wearing batty boy" Namath?
Brad Johnson was
RhodyRum
Mark Gassed-A-Heaux
Brad Johnson won a title. Who was Bama's last? Joe "panty hose wearing batty boy" Namath?
Kenny Stabler
Edit: As to who'll be the better pro QB, the first pic in the first post tells you who WON'T be much at the pro level. Unless your name is Bernie Kosar or Phillip Rivers, that low angle, sidearm delivery can go kick rocks. He also plays in a system AND for a coach who, combined, have horrible track records for developing even the basics for quarterbacking at the pro level.
Last edited:
Alex Smith was a Pro Bowler.
Having said that,Im going with Winston for now. Let's see how Cardale progresses by the end of the year. He's still raw. But Jameis has proven himself over multiple seasons and is more developed right now.
Jameis hasn't started a NFL game that counts, Cardale hasn't started a home game in college yet . Jameis got more experience give him the nod for now
. Jameis got more experience give him the nod for now
RhodyRum
Mark Gassed-A-Heaux
Smith became a Pro Bowler a full 9 seasons after leaving Utah and after working with 2 QB guru head coaches in Harbaugh & Reid. And even during his Renaissance, he still got benched for Kaep, who ain't nothing special himself.
Mentioning Smith does nothing to boost up Meyer's QB reputation.
Wrong. Harbaugh just used the skill set that Alex had that made him the number 1 overall pick much better than his previous coaches. Credit goes to Jim for recognizing his forgotten strengths Alex learned under Urb. The talent was always there,just needed the right coach to develop him further. Quit moving goal posts.
Eye Cue DA COLI GAWD
<--- Cleveland Browns winning that many, boi!
It's just something about Cardale. This guy is the equivalent of one of those future cars actually being made and finding its way on the car lot lol.
There has maybe never been a more physically blessed QB in the last 40 years as Cardale. Add to that, the guy simply has UNCANNY down field accuracy. Even that endzone incompletion to Braxton was where the ball needed to be, Braxton just had a quick misstep in the route.
This is a good thread. I'm glad Cardale is starting this season. By the end of the year I expect this guy to simply be a beast.
There has maybe never been a more physically blessed QB in the last 40 years as Cardale. Add to that, the guy simply has UNCANNY down field accuracy. Even that endzone incompletion to Braxton was where the ball needed to be, Braxton just had a quick misstep in the route.
This is a good thread. I'm glad Cardale is starting this season. By the end of the year I expect this guy to simply be a beast.
Caredale has played 4 better teams than Jameis career
Caredale actually beat the team that embarrassed Jameis
So that VT team that Cardale beat is better than any team Jameis played?
Nice to see Cardale gets credit for beating a scrub ACC team and Jameis doesn't 
Last edited:
QuarterCenturyLegend
Stoopid Life
So that VT team that Cardale is better than any team Jameis played?
Oh, he didn't make fun of Bama & Oregon? Not even gonna bring up Wisconsin. Chill with that
I realize all those teams you mentioned are good and Cardale clowned them. I specifically pointed out VT because the poster included them as being better than any team Jameis has ever played and I disagree they're not
