He's "half-assing" it on defense, in this context those numbers are irrelevant, because they do come at a cost of him not applying the same amount of effort on defense. Now obviously I don't think it should be expected of him to be a lockdown defender for the entire game, but I don't think his surface numbers should be valued as highly as they do if he's ignoring the other end + ignoring the benefit of not dominating the ball as much as he does.
I know personally, I would value his play a lot more if he didn't control the ball/possessions to put up pretty box score numbers, and replaced it with more off-ball play and focus on defense. The team would be better off for it too.
I agree he's half-assing it on defense, I just have trouble expecting him to do anything else at this point in the season/career. A LOT of older stars half-ass it on defense during the regular season, especially early on, especially when they're expected to take massive responsibilities on offense and have been making deep, exhaustive playoff runs for a decade and counting. The team should be compensating for him there, because a good bit of them are younger, healthier, and aren't really doing shyt on either end.
I spoke about this last season too, it's half the reason why their defense is as bad as it is, because they're just following his lead. They'd still have the same foundational issues on that end, but they'd be A LOT better if he took a backseat on offense and put more focus on defense.
Just like he would've put them in a better position of winning the Finals last season if he balanced his effort on defense/offense in accordance to what his team needed. Folks keep going on about how great his Finals performance was (due to being distracted by his pretty box score #s), but it really wasn't.
Take a backseat on offense and let...Wade lead the team on that side? Shump? DRose in the half of the games that he's shown up for?
You're talking about a team that has gone to three straight Finals and won one of the biggest rings in history. And you give them a lineup that doesn't look like it has a chance in hell of stopping one of the most stacked teams in history. What is the motivation going to be? It's no surprise at all that moral is low. What are they playing for? They gotta be either just waiting for more trades or expecting to mail the season in.
Even if Lebron put more focus on defense, they would still have massive deficiencies there at every position. When you're starting DRose at PG, 35yo JR at SG, Love at PF, and this version of TT at center, you are going to have defensive issues regardless of how hard Lebron plays. And with JR and TT basically being black holes on offense at the moment, Lebron taking a step back there would mean your offense revolving around...Rose and Love's two-man game?
This team doesn't have the personnel to compete. I said that from the moment Kyrie was traded.