Ask your new best friend for the definition of "push polling"
DOESN'T WORK WHEN WE CHANGE KOBE TO T-MAC:
That’s a spicy take, and it’s rooted in some interesting cultural dynamics around sports debates — but
no, it's not
exactly true.
Let’s break it down:
Why “analytic nerds” favor LeBron:
- Advanced stats love LeBron. He’s a statistical monster — PER, Win Shares, Box Plus/Minus, VORP, True Shooting %, etc.
- He has an unmatched combination of scoring, passing, rebounding, and efficiency.
- LeBron’s longevity and consistency are nearly unprecedented.
- Analytics also value his decision-making and basketball IQ, which are elite.
- Data-driven fans often place high value on impact metrics, and LeBron rates near or at the top of most.
Why some “hoopers” or players love T-Mac:
- T-Mac’s raw talent was off the charts. His size + handle + shot-making were ahead of his time.
- He had that “bag” that hoopers love — the ability to create shots off the dribble, isolate, make tough buckets.
- Many players relate to the aesthetic of how T-Mac played — smooth, fluid, effortless.
- Kobe Bryant famously said T-Mac was the hardest player he ever guarded.
- There’s a sense that "real hoopers" recognize real", and T-Mac had that artistry that goes beyond the box score.

The Real Answer:
- It’s a false dichotomy to say it’s nerds = LeBron and athletes = T-Mac.
- Plenty of ex-players and current NBA stars rank LeBron as the GOAT (or at least top 2).
- Plenty of analytically savvy fans also recognize T-Mac’s brilliance, even if his career was shorter and lacked playoff success.
Why this narrative exists:
- There’s a cultural divide in basketball debates:
“Hoopers vs. basketball players”
(i.e., eye test and skill vs. numbers and impact).
- T-Mac is often seen as a “hooper’s hooper”, whereas LeBron is seen as a “winning basketball player” whose game isn’t always flashy but is always effective.
- The mythos of unfulfilled greatness around T-Mac adds to his allure — especially for players who feel how hard it is to do what he did.
Bottom Line:
- Most people — nerds, hoopers, fans, players — respect both.
- LeBron is objectively one of the greatest of all time.
- T-Mac is a “what-if legend” who earns major respect for his raw skill and style.
So, your statement has
some cultural relevance behind it, but it’s more of a social media meme than an accurate reflection of opinion across the board.
LOL