Which of these Pharcyde and Hieroglyphics albums are classic?


  • Total voters
    30
  • Poll closed .
Joined
Feb 14, 2014
Messages
257,707
Reputation
53,967
Daps
562,436
yeah my point is nothing is set in stone. I think Common has 3 classics, Em has 1 at least, G Rap has a couple or so. But also, they aren't set in stone like a Cuban Linx/36 Chambers etc. so we test out how consensus they really are

follow the hash tag and you won't miss another thread

@Zero I thought Full Circle was pretty decent actually, and actually like it more than their debut
:ehh:

i think for the most part, it's pretty set in stone with what's a classic and what's not

that's not to say you ain't gon come across an album by artist that some maybe on the fence about but for the most part, it's pretty set in stone what is an what ain't

but it's all good :ehh:
 

yo moms

drunk
Joined
Mar 19, 2013
Messages
21,895
Reputation
-164
Daps
24,063
ok, maybe when it was posted it just wasn't a very busy time or maybe some other thread were poppin' at that moment

i don't know, sometimes it just depends

nah look at all the pharcyde threads. they all dead. this aimt no coincedence. how was i the first one to make a runnin appreciation thread and it got like 9 replies. :dead:

for some reason the coli doesnt jnow who they are :russ:
 

Inspect Her Deck

Skins of all colours come together as brothers
Joined
Dec 14, 2015
Messages
8,911
Reputation
1,546
Daps
19,946
i think for the most part, it's pretty set in stone with what's a classic and what's not

that's not to say you ain't gon come across an album by artist that some maybe on the fence about but for the most part, it's pretty set in stone what is an what ain't

but it's all good :ehh:

if you go to the link I put in the OP called "Official Classics Discussion Thread" or something like that, you'll have the updated list of classics. See for yourself if that was what you expected or nah, just to see how people have been voting. It's updated for DJ Quik as well, his results just came in.
 

IAmListenin'

Rookie
Joined
Dec 26, 2015
Messages
233
Reputation
70
Daps
423
i mean, but it's pretty well known what's what though. i ain't tryin' to be a dikk or nothin' but unless someone just started listenin' to hip hop in the last 5 to 10 years, then they know or grew up with these classics, so it's kinda like we statin' the obvious :yeshrug:

Not necessarily. To take The Predator as an example, I have a cousin who's older than I am who'd never heard it before. My cousin, brother and I were together, and I was talking to my brother about a song on it and I included my cousin in the conversation since my brother wasn't born yet when The Predator dropped and thus wouldn't be familiar with the song, but he didn't know what I was talking about either. I was in high school when it dropped and he was in his early twenties at the time, so seeing how I clearly remember it I was baffled as to how he could have gone without ever hearing it, but somehow he had.

There have been other occasions where I've just assumed there's a shared understanding when I'm talking to people in my age group or above and was wrong. When talking to people younger than me, I assume they largely wouldn't be familiar with the music I grew up with (which is usually the case) unless they've demonstrated an interest in the history of the genre (I've conversed with younger people who are familiar with and enjoy what is "older" music to them), but people in my age bracket lived through the same period of time, so if they listen to hip-hop in the first place, one would think there'd be certain things they would have heard at some point, but this isn't always the case. For instance, one woman I talked to who was a couple of years older than me knew who Heavy D was, but somehow didn't know who Big Daddy Kane was. So sometimes I have no idea what people pay attention to.
 
Joined
Feb 14, 2014
Messages
257,707
Reputation
53,967
Daps
562,436
Not necessarily. To take The Predator as an example, I have a cousin who's older than I am who'd never heard it before. My cousin, brother and I were together, and I was talking to my brother about a song on it and I included my cousin in the conversation since my brother wasn't born yet when The Predator dropped and thus wouldn't be familiar with the song, but he didn't know what I was talking about either. I was in high school when it dropped and he was in his early twenties at the time, so seeing how I clearly remember it I was baffled as to how he could have gone without ever hearing it when we're both on the West Coast, but somehow he had.

There have been other occasions where I've just assumed there's a shared understanding when I'm talking to people in my age group or above and was wrong. When talking to people younger than me, I assume they largely wouldn't be familiar with the music I grew up with (which is usually the case) unless they've demonstrated an interest in the history of the genre (I've conversed with younger people who are familiar with and enjoy what is "older" music to them), but people in my age bracket lived through the same period of time, so if they listen to hip-hop in the first place, one would think there'd be certain things they would have heard at some point, but this isn't always the case. For instance, one woman I talked to who was a couple of years older than me knew who Heavy D was, but somehow didn't know who Big Daddy Kane was. So sometimes I have no idea what people pay attention to.

:ehh:
 

phatphuck

Pro
Joined
Jun 10, 2012
Messages
1,383
Reputation
120
Daps
1,321
Reppin
NULL
this is really difficult, bizarre and third eye vision are very enjoyable albums that i'd rate somewhere in between the range of 4.5 to 5. but are they classics amongst the likes of it takes a nation, 36 chambers, low end theory etc? no

i guess their only flaw is lacking impactwise
 

Big Mel

@bigboss
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
28,407
Reputation
-3,213
Daps
34,933
Reppin
Flodge free zone
I'd argue both Pharcyde albums are classics and win. Bizarre Ride is indisputable though.

Hiero's run from 1993-4 is rife with arguable classics. '93 Till is probably the one that's most recognized for sharing a classic song of the same name but No Need For Alarm & Fear Itself are just as good. Extra Pro is slept on.

I Wish My Brother George Was Here > The Predator, MAAD Circle & KAM
 
Top