its funny, if Seahawks hand the ball off to Lynch, Brady has 3 straight SB losses, and no rings in 14 years, while going for a 4th straight loss this year. 
Clayton's GOAT quarterback ranking
- Thread starter Street Knowledge
- Start date
NOSaintsFan02
Superstar
How can you not have Brees in your top 15? Hell, in your top 10?
Don't Rodgers and Brees have the same amount of Super Bowl wins and appearances?
The disrespect.
Don't Rodgers and Brees have the same amount of Super Bowl wins and appearances?
The disrespect.
Elway played in an antiquated offensive scheme when he put up those numbers. Dan Reeves' offense was behind the times. Bronco WR Steve Watson called it the Edsel System.
John put up much better numbers in college. In 1993, when Dan Reeves went to the Giants, and Fassel (Elway's college QB coach) came on board, Elway's numbers vastly improved.
I AM WARHOL
Veteran
*Sees #1. Smiles. Leaves thread*
duckbutta
eienaar van mans
The issue with Bradshaw is that he got 4 rings...so if you want to try and discredit him to whatever degree...you got to do that...4 times...and that's pretty difficult to do...
If we are talking about talent at the QB level then it's Rodgers...there just hast never been a QB with his combination of arm strength, accuracy, and IQ
And with that said I don't have Rodgers on the same planet as Montana and Brady...Montana and Brady have their own planet...because they both have elite levels of the things that Rodgers is the outright elite at...BUT...they have so many more super bowl wins and in Brady's case appearances than him...
I just don't even understand how you can make a QB list and 1 and 2 is not Brady and Montana...
If we are talking about talent at the QB level then it's Rodgers...there just hast never been a QB with his combination of arm strength, accuracy, and IQ
And with that said I don't have Rodgers on the same planet as Montana and Brady...Montana and Brady have their own planet...because they both have elite levels of the things that Rodgers is the outright elite at...BUT...they have so many more super bowl wins and in Brady's case appearances than him...
I just don't even understand how you can make a QB list and 1 and 2 is not Brady and Montana...
Foxmulder
Superstar
Sadly history won't remember it this way. I dont know how the fukk anyone could put Brady over Montana.its funny, if Seahawks hand the ball off to Lynch, Brady has 3 straight SB losses, and no rings in 14 years, while going for a 4th straight loss this year.
Ive said this before that there isnt a GOAT qb in the nfl because too many players have played that position at such a high level to just single one out. But u can easily make a list of qbs without factoring rings. Rings is a team effort. Unless brady or montana or even rodgers is winning SBs with scrubs on offense and defense and truly carrying the team,then rings can easily be tossed out when arguing about the goat.
10 tds 17 picks in his prime...if the offense was so archaic, why did he throw so many picks...
Omar Little
It’s all in the Game Yo
No Brees or Young= fukk this pedo looking CAC
Because elway was a qb who wouldnt succeed unless he was surrounded by good players. Sad but true. He wasnt the type to carry a team or make anyone better.
BlueHeffner
Veteran
Breh, give it up already. Brady is GOAT
Foxmulder
Superstar
Nah Joe is the GOAT.Breh, give it up already. Brady is GOAT
