Clayton's GOAT quarterback ranking
- Thread starter Street Knowledge
- Start date
T.he I.nformant
1st Ballot HOF Teller
#7 
Copy Ninja
Superstar
at the people diminishing Brady because he doesn't 'wow' them with amazing physical feats at the QB position (Sportscenter mentality
)If it was about physical skills or natural talent, Kyle Boller would be a HOF.
QB is about
1. reading defenses
2. making the right decisions
3. throwing an accurate pass
Brady does the first two better than anyone that has ever played
And his accuracy is as good as anyone's
DetroitEWarren
Veteran
Breh, give it up already. Brady is GOAT
its really fukkin crazy to me that everytime the "history altering" play call is mentioned, literally not a single person EVER mentions that Seattle only got down there cause of a great defensive play that ended up being a mistake cause the reciever caught the ball on the ground after a tip. BRADY HAD ALREADY WON TGE fukkIN GAME WITH HIS DOMINANT 4TH QUARTER. 1 lucky ass play was the only reason SEA even had a fukkin chance. On top of that, Beast Mode would have still had to score the fukkin TD. Teams have been stopped on the 1 yard line numerous times.nikkas are furious that Brady wins ALL QB debates. Rather it's career, numbers, skills, popularity, etc. nikkas hate the greats
Womb Raider
5* Gooneral
Yeah, he was
If it was about physical skills or natural talent, Kyle Boller would be a HOF.
QB is about
1. reading defenses
2. making the right decisions
3. throwing an accurate pass
Brady does the first two better than anyone that has ever played
And his accuracy is as good as anyone's
nikkas are furious that Brady wins ALL QB debates. Rather it's career, numbers, skills, popularity, etc. nikkas hate the greats
what skills does Brady win over other QB's? enlighten me please
DetroitEWarren
Veteran
The GOAT accuracy off rip. Top 3 OAT arm strength, GOAT field vision, top 5 "pocket footwork", best pass fake I ever seen, etc.
But let me explain before nikkas start calling me crazy.
Rodgers is not a more accurate passer than Brady, especially standing still in the pocket or after slight movements. Rodgers is inflated because of his elite mobility WITH THAT MOBILITY YOU FREE UP YOUR RECIEVERS JUST AS MUCH AS U FREE YOURSELF UP. Off rip that is making completing passes easier IF U CAN THROW ON THE MOVE. Rodgers ability to throw on the move is GOAT level, that doesn't make him a more accurate passer just means that his feet gets his recievers more open than a stand still Brady.
Arm strength???? Brady has been one of the hardest bullet passers for the last 16 years and he flings the ball 70+ yards with ease, Rodgers hail Marys is much more of a play by the recievers than anything to do with Rodgers arm.
Decision making and field vision is Brady's by so much that u would be crazy to question it.
Dawg, I'm fukkin
. I don't even know if I stated my point correctly. Goodnight bro. Lock my door on your way out and call me when u get to the crib. Police is hot as fukk out here right now, be safe.
madness
Taking my talents to South Beach
marino's release was a thing of beauty
why didnt they get that man a running game
why didnt they get that man a running game
David_TheMan
Banned
1. Montana
2. Marino
3. Kelly
============ All 3 get bonus to me because they didn't play in era the catered to offense and inflated stats
4. Brady
5. Manning
6. Fouts
7. Farve
8. Elway
9. Unitas
10. Rodgers
2. Marino
3. Kelly
============ All 3 get bonus to me because they didn't play in era the catered to offense and inflated stats
4. Brady
5. Manning
6. Fouts
7. Farve
8. Elway
9. Unitas
10. Rodgers
The GOAT accuracy off rip. Top 3 OAT arm strength, GOAT field vision, top 5 "pocket footwork", best pass fake I ever seen, etc.
But let me explain before nikkas start calling me crazy.
Rodgers is not a more accurate passer than Brady, especially standing still in the pocket or after slight movements. Rodgers is inflated because of his elite mobility WITH THAT MOBILITY YOU FREE UP YOUR RECIEVERS JUST AS MUCH AS U FREE YOURSELF UP. Off rip that is making completing passes easier IF U CAN THROW ON THE MOVE. Rodgers ability to throw on the move is GOAT level, that doesn't make him a more accurate passer just means that his feet gets his recievers more open than a stand still Brady.
Arm strength???? Brady has been one of the hardest bullet passers for the last 16 years and he flings the ball 70+ yards with ease, Rodgers hail Marys is much more of a play by the recievers than anything to do with Rodgers arm.
Decision making and field vision is Brady's by so much that u would be crazy to question it.
Dawg, I'm fukkin
yea u drunk breh. sleep it off
Elway is not in my top 5 or my top ten. He was at best the 5th best qb of his own era. Marino,Montana,Favre, and Young were all clearly superior.
If you're the 5th best guy of your own era, how can you be top 5 of all time?
If you're the 5th best guy of your own era, how can you be top 5 of all time?
feelosofer
#ninergang
Montana is still #1, but I gotta be honest, if Brady get's another ring, Brady is going to replace him.
