Clayton's GOAT quarterback ranking

[TrebleMan]

I agree with the list, except Brees is definitely top 10. Also don't se the hype about Elway.

#1 ranked defense with Terrell Davis having a crazy two-year stretch, a mean OL, Rod Smith + Shannon Sharpe as weapons. A game manager could win a Super Bowl with that.

That 2nd championship run dude's defense got 3,6 and 4 turnovers respectfully in each of the play-off games and the Super Bowl.

 

[Jbsptfn]

Because elway was a qb who wouldnt succeed unless he was surrounded by good players. Sad but true. He wasnt the type to carry a team or make anyone better.

He carried the Broncos to three SB's in the 80's without a good supporting cast. I don't know where you get that crap.

 

[XxBboyxX]

He carried the Broncos to three SB's in the 80's without a good supporting cast. I don't know where you get that crap.

 

[O.iatlhawksfan]

Brees not top 10?

 

[Regular_P]

1. Montana
2. Marino
3. Kelly
============ All 3 get bonus to me because they didn't play in era the catered to offense and inflated stats
4. Brady
5. Manning
6. Fouts
7. Farve
8. Elway
9. Unitas
10. Rodgers

This fool has Jim Kelly third.

 

[David_TheMan]

This fool has Jim Kelly third.

My opinion, you can feel free to disagree.

 

[premier58]

I love how he just glosses over thw facts about Elway I posted like they werent even there..

 

[Jbsptfn]

I love how he just glosses over thw facts about Elway I posted like they werent even there..

You talking about 1992? Elway missed about five of the last six games. And, that offense was awful that year. He had no weapons around him.

The next year, Reeves left, and he had a great year as I talked about before. Why didn't you address that?

 

[AlbertPullhoez]

Roger should be top 10. He dominated his era

Staubach could've been hands down GOAT if he didn't spend 5 years in the military

Id take him over some modern day QB's

 

[premier58]

You talking about 1992? Elway missed about five of the last six games. And, that offense was awful that year. He had no weapons around him.

The next year, Reeves left, and he had a great year as I talked about before. Why didn't you address that?

The truly greats dont have awful years like that..what about 89?? Throwing 18 tds and 18 picka but somehow getting credited for carrying the No. 1 scoring defense..fukk Elway, he wasnt even on Jim Kellys level..

 

[Versa]

Can't respect a top 10 list that has Terry Bradshaw on it but not Steve Young and Drew Brees.

Horrible list.

 

[K-Deini]

wheres eli?

 

[HabitualChiller]

Elway is not in my top 5 or my top ten. He was at best the 5th best qb of his own era. Marino,Montana,Favre, and Young were all clearly superior.

If you're the 5th best guy of your own era, how can you be top 5 of all time?

Literally all of those guys you listed had a much better team/coach than Elway. What does clearly superior mean? How is leading 3 below average teams to super bowls considered inferior?

 

[HabitualChiller]

The GOAT accuracy off rip. Top 3 OAT arm strength, GOAT field vision, top 5 "pocket footwork", best pass fake I ever seen, etc.

But let me explain before nikkas start calling me crazy.


Rodgers is not a more accurate passer than Brady, especially standing still in the pocket or after slight movements. Rodgers is inflated because of his elite mobility WITH THAT MOBILITY YOU FREE UP YOUR RECIEVERS JUST AS MUCH AS U FREE YOURSELF UP. Off rip that is making completing passes easier IF U CAN THROW ON THE MOVE. Rodgers ability to throw on the move is GOAT level, that doesn't make him a more accurate passer just means that his feet gets his recievers more open than a stand still Brady.

Arm strength???? Brady has been one of the hardest bullet passers for the last 16 years and he flings the ball 70+ yards with ease, Rodgers hail Marys is much more of a play by the recievers than anything to do with Rodgers arm.

Decision making and field vision is Brady's by so much that u would be crazy to question it.

Dawg, I'm fukkin . I don't even know if I stated my point correctly. Goodnight bro. Lock my door on your way out and call me when u get to the crib. Police is hot as fukk out here right now, be safe.

1st.

2nd: Farve and Big Ben had better ones

 

[Reggie]

Terry and them rings keeps him in the top 10 discussion when he really doesn't belong. Especially not over guys like Brees Young Moon etc.