Yeah, it doesn't make sense. The first part makes it seem like they've had sex more than once, but then the second part makes it seem like they met for the first time Jan 25th/26th.conflicting accounts
I think what happened was that they were 'sexting' on kik, and then when they finally met on the 25/26th that's when Carlton realized Tyrone/Tyra was a man. So I'm guessing there was no FaceTiming/sky ping etc. going on.