Come help me settle an argument.. Reggie Miller VS Brandon Roy

[904]

Injuries and longevity aside.. Both players at their best

@houston911
@Malta
@Gil Scott-Heroin
@Sonny Corinthos
@Brozay
@Black

 

[Ruck]

reggie

 

[Black]

Roy

 

[Malta]

It's hard to do this comparison because we never got to see Roy in his prime, look at the kind of numbers Harden & Westbrook are putting up at 27 and 28, and the last time we saw Roy at his best he was only 25.

 

[SchoolboyC]

The answer has to be Reggie simply for the fact that we never really got to see what Roy at his best could be. Injuries got the best of him when he was like 25

 

[Imyremeshaw]

Reggie - as a shooter, clutch and somewhat defender

Brandon Roy - Everything else, playmaking, rebounding, just more well rounded....

Ill take Brandon Roy over Reggie except in a game 7 or clutch last second shot.....

 

[str8up]

I'd definitely go with Roy, assuming that he would stay healthy, Reggie was the man tho.

 

[BaldingSoHard]

Roy.

 

[CarltonJunior]

"Injuries and longevity aside"

So throwing out the fact that one is a hall of famer and had a long career and one only played 5 seasons, I'll just say this. Reggie is an all-time great shooter and a great player to have on your team because he's the ultimate off ball player. He's clutch but so is Roy

Roy is better with the ball in his hands, but he's far less consistent as a shooter

Im taking Reggie

 

[Brozay]

Different players, I would go with Roy if I'm starting a team by scratch. Just more well rounded

 

[Gil Scott-Heroin]

Reggie.

Although it isn't a fair comparison given we never got to see Roy at his best.

 

[ShoryukenHaduken]

Reggie

rather take the consistant shooter

if reggie even had gotten some handles

 

[GreatestLaker]

I would take a 24 year old Brandon Roy over any version Reggie Miller.

 

[904]

The argument stemmed from one of us saying that Reggie was overrated and there are 10 SGs they'd take from 96 onward before Reggie.. Roy's name came up and now we're here...

Gotta love NBA arguments

 

[mitter]

Reggie Miller is one of the most overrated players in NBA history