Cuphead and the Racist Spectre of Fleischer Animation

DPresidential

The Coli's Ralph Ellison
Supporter
Joined
Oct 31, 2012
Messages
25,538
Reputation
13,727
Daps
103,868
Reppin
Old Brooklyn
Yeah, it would be difficult, but I think that burden should come with them deciding to use this source material.

They've done plenty of videos on the art style, why it was chosen and how they executed it. I think a video or two about the racist history of the art and how they made sure avoid stereotypes would have been a good way to respect that history and educate.

Again, I'm not really criticizing them, just offering solutions going forward
No, you're absolutely right.
 

Rekkapryde

GT, LWO, 49ERS, BRAVES, HAWKS, N4O...yeah UMAD!
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
158,375
Reputation
31,320
Daps
537,317
Reppin
TYRONE GA!
There would be a party going on if this were a Sony game :troll:

All jokes aside, if they don't have any black caricatures in the game then this really is an overreaction clickbait article.

Also don't agree with the censorship of those old cartoons either. Put a disclaimer out there before it starts. Don't rewrite history, show what it was so people can know better.
 

daze23

Siempre Fresco
Joined
Jun 25, 2012
Messages
32,562
Reputation
2,745
Daps
45,276
I really don’t want a history lesson from a video game though...Call of Duty WW II just came out. The new assassin creed set in Egypt etc. do we really want an explanation from everything just to prove it’s not racist?
most of history is abhorrent by modern standards. it's filled with racism, slavery and other forms of servitude, torture, genocide, persecution for all types of shyt, nobility and incest, etc
 

Black Hans

Follow Jesus. Be Beautiful
Supporter
Joined
May 8, 2012
Messages
8,326
Reputation
-1,201
Daps
20,320
Reppin
John 14:6
:mjlol::stopitslime::comeon::camby:

Nah, I'ma keep playing it. There aren't any jigaboo caricatures in Cuphead, breh. Stop it. I'm starting to see why people get at what they call SJWs.
 

TripleAgent

Tired of Coli faqs
Supporter
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
38,874
Reputation
7,225
Daps
99,659
Reppin
Baltimore
It really is imo

Like, I get what the writer's complaint is - but its really disingenuous for them to hit the artists here for this. The entire animation style itself is representative of America's early entertainment history which in itself was built upon passively or actively shytting on every community out there. The game is built on said art style and always was. So, should they detour away from the reality of what it was? Should they try and reinvent or re-imagine that style to be safe against potential sensational articles like this one?

People complaining about Mario/Nintendo games having no black people have more ground to speak on. By a lot.
This.
 

firemanBk

The Manslayer
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
15,106
Reputation
1,741
Daps
41,708
Reppin
Brooklyn
There would be a party going on if this were a Sony game :troll:

All jokes aside, if they don't have any black caricatures in the game then this really is an overreaction clickbait article.

Also don't agree with the censorship of those old cartoons either. Put a disclaimer out there before it starts. Don't rewrite history, show what it was so people can know better.

100% agree

People have a right to know what those times were like. Trying to ignore it or gloss over it is worse to me

Otherwise, we end up with shyt like this

 

Ill Lou Malnati

Be Well.
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
27,597
Reputation
2,803
Daps
68,575
Interesting read, but I agree this is a reach. Were cartoons in the 1930s incredibly insensitive and racist at times? Yeah, certain ones were, but that doesn't mean the entire 1930s style of animation is. Sorry, I don't see a "racist spectre" looming over a video game like this.
 

winb83

52 Years Young
Supporter
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
48,354
Reputation
4,148
Daps
72,863
Reppin
Michigan
Excellent article. Not sure how anyone can support this game.
I didn't even buy the game but I fail to see how it having an art style that some racist cartoons also happened to use means anything about the game itself and racism. Are we implying all cartoons back then were racist.
 

PS5 Pro

DC looking a 1/2 seed right about nuh
Joined
Feb 28, 2013
Messages
32,346
Reputation
-10,551
Daps
22,201
Reppin
The Original Rec Room Gang
I really don’t want a history lesson from a video game though...Call of Duty WW II just came out. The new assassin creed set in Egypt etc. do we really want an explanation from everything just to prove it’s not racist?
I believe Assassins creed is racist because they white washed, cuphead doesn't involve "people" so this article is bullshyt
Pathetic click bait
What you talking about, unwinnable.com be having the FIRE stories bruh. @Responsible Allen Iverson keep lacing us with these Malcolm Z articles :wow:
 

MeachTheMonster

YourFriendlyHoodMonster
Joined
May 24, 2012
Messages
73,559
Reputation
4,269
Daps
116,624
Reppin
Tha Land
Interesting read, but I agree this is a reach. Were cartoons in the 1930s incredibly insensitive and racist at times? Yeah, certain ones were, but that doesn't mean the entire 1930s style of animation is. Sorry, I don't see a "racist spectre" looming over a video game like this.
To the writers point, it's not just that the 1930s style is racist. It's the theme of gambling, jazz, and the devil being related that comes directly from racist stereotypes.

So even in attempting to avoid the racism of the time, their designs are inherently racist by virtue.

That's doesn't make them racists. But their explanation that they were avoiding racism altogether doesn't fly if you really understand the history.
 
Top