I identify with this so much! I'm an introvert, but I know how to interact with people at the same time. I keep to myself, my siblings, and a very small circle of friends. Plenty of acquaintances though! My siblings always tell me how "square" I am, but I don't care.
Guys that I've met (when out with friends, didn't care to be out... Just went to socialize--the lyrics in Alessia Cara's "Here" really describes me when out with friends) have later told me how confused I made them as they got to know me, because I really am not about that "I need constant validation from men so I go out every week" life, but you can't tell by looking at me/having seen me out a night or two.
I'm often assumed to have dudes lined up, been called a "heartbreaker," old co worker (who was also a Kappa so he was used to having it thrown at him) told me once "you look like you're going to meet your man and get busted down." I said "no, going to dinner with one of my girls from high school so we can catch up, but I just wanted to wear shorts and heels today. I'm a virgin anyway, but I wear what I want." He had the most shocked look on his face! That was 5 years ago, at 23. I'm still a virgin today... And I mean 100%. I don't know why that's so perplexing!
It is possible to look good, and be a quiet homebody (I'm also kind of a nerd because I love and taught myself some HTML and CSS coding in high school) who is about her business. I just want to focus on making sure I have a career and more than "good looks" in life. Has a lot to do with how I was raised!
Edit: I was not sheltered as a child, just the most introverted one out of the 4 of us children. I was the intellectual child! So I guess that made me "boring," too which presents a paradox when having an attractive (as I've been told) look and personality because it doesn't line up with one's perception. Especially that of a female.
I'm just unapologetically me though, and you either accept me or you don't, but you never define me.